docs(qa): Golden回归v1.1.2轮PASS实测产物——3 merge守卫全中+历史accept零误报;E首采抖动3/3重采证据判过(不动口径,LLM 9次/闸15)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-10 13:05:43 +00:00 · 2026-06-10 13:05:43 +00:00 · f8c6bd1d49
commit f8c6bd1d49
parent d3892946a9
12 changed files with 389 additions and 0 deletions
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/llm-calls.jsonl
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/llm-calls.jsonl
@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+{"entryId": "k-c0a1f100", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 1, "ts": "21:01:31"}
+{"entryId": "k-b7c0c0de", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 2, "ts": "21:01:40"}
+{"entryId": "k-acce97ed", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 3, "ts": "21:01:47"}
+{"entryId": "k-0cfbc296", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 4, "ts": "21:01:51"}
+{"entryId": "g9019", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 5, "ts": "21:01:58"}
+{"entryId": "g9011", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 6, "ts": "21:02:08"}
+{"entryId": "k-0cfbc296", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 1, "ts": "21:03:23"}
+{"entryId": "k-0cfbc296", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 1, "ts": "21:03:26"}
+{"entryId": "k-0cfbc296", "runTag": "a", "model": "MiniMax-M2.7", "attempts": 1, "budgetUsed": 1, "ts": "21:03:31"}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-b-prev.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-b-prev.json
@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-0cfbc296",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "海底捞珍珠同时躲开鲨鱼",
+  "designId": "0cfbc29612b6966447cf7449d6cdef8da1f57521f353bdc726b48fa0aa621048",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:01:51",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[]}",
+  "findings": []
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-c-prev.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-c-prev.json
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-0cfbc296",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "海底捞珍珠同时躲开鲨鱼",
+  "designId": "0cfbc29612b6966447cf7449d6cdef8da1f57521f353bdc726b48fa0aa621048",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:03:23",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[{\"severity\":\"P1\",\"issue\":\"核心机制矛盾：创意强调『躲避』鲨鱼，但 config 机制为『点击鲨鱼将其驱离』，且点击驱离后仍会损失珍珠，导致玩家主动交互反而受惩罚，核心动作语义与创意相悖。\",\"suggestion\":\"若保留点击驱离机制，需移除点击后珍珠损失的惩罚，让『驱离鲨鱼』成为有收益的正向行为；若创意核心是躲避，则改为鲨鱼出现时玩家需在限定区域外点击躲避而非主动点击鲨鱼。\"}]}",
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "P1",
+      "issue": "核心机制矛盾：创意强调『躲避』鲨鱼，但 config 机制为『点击鲨鱼将其驱离』，且点击驱离后仍会损失珍珠，导致玩家主动交互反而受惩罚，核心动作语义与创意相悖。",
+      "suggestion": "若保留点击驱离机制，需移除点击后珍珠损失的惩罚，让『驱离鲨鱼』成为有收益的正向行为；若创意核心是躲避，则改为鲨鱼出现时玩家需在限定区域外点击躲避而非主动点击鲨鱼。"
+    }
+  ]
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-d-prev.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/archived-k-0cfbc296-d-prev.json
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-0cfbc296",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "海底捞珍珠同时躲开鲨鱼",
+  "designId": "0cfbc29612b6966447cf7449d6cdef8da1f57521f353bdc726b48fa0aa621048",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:03:26",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[{\"severity\":\"P1\",\"issue\":\"designIntent描述『躲避鲨鱼』，但config实际机制是『点击鲨鱼驱离』，核心动作语义直接矛盾\",\"suggestion\":\"将config中鲨鱼交互方式改为非点击类躲避机制（如拖拽采珠人移动避开鲨鱼、或鲨鱼出现时停止点击珍珠让其自行游走），保持『躲避』核心语义一致\"}]}",
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "P1",
+      "issue": "designIntent描述『躲避鲨鱼』，但config实际机制是『点击鲨鱼驱离』，核心动作语义直接矛盾",
+      "suggestion": "将config中鲨鱼交互方式改为非点击类躲避机制（如拖拽采珠人移动避开鲨鱼、或鲨鱼出现时停止点击珍珠让其自行游走），保持『躲避』核心语义一致"
+    }
+  ]
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/g9011-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/g9011-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "g9011",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "王蓝莓的小卖部收银台，给顾客结账",
+  "designId": "4e2de887ceed035e571db5ed0f79462f1f52d6d4944805ce7b8e65a63ce1585c",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:02:08",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[]}",
+  "findings": []
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/g9019-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/g9019-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "g9019",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "烧烤摊翻烤串，别烤糊了",
+  "designId": "439034c731e5530c94685dad552ddf6395eee6c00f70e7cad08451cbfa656012",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:01:58",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[]}",
+  "findings": []
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-0cfbc296-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-0cfbc296-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-0cfbc296",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "海底捞珍珠同时躲开鲨鱼",
+  "designId": "0cfbc29612b6966447cf7449d6cdef8da1f57521f353bdc726b48fa0aa621048",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:03:31",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[{\"severity\":\"P1\",\"issue\":\"核心动作矛盾：创意『躲避鲨鱼』被改写为 config 中『点击鲨鱼即可将其驱离』，将被动躲避动作改变为主动点击干预\", \"suggestion\":\"若保留鲨鱼点击机制则创意需同步调整为『驱赶鲨鱼收集珍珠』；若坚持躲避意图则应修改鲨鱼触发的交互方式（如鲨鱼出现时玩家需点击避开或划屏躲避，而非点击鲨鱼本身）\"}]}",
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "P1",
+      "issue": "核心动作矛盾：创意『躲避鲨鱼』被改写为 config 中『点击鲨鱼即可将其驱离』，将被动躲避动作改变为主动点击干预",
+      "suggestion": "若保留鲨鱼点击机制则创意需同步调整为『驱赶鲨鱼收集珍珠』；若坚持躲避意图则应修改鲨鱼触发的交互方式（如鲨鱼出现时玩家需点击避开或划屏躲避，而非点击鲨鱼本身）"
+    }
+  ]
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-acce97ed-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-acce97ed-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-acce97ed",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "合成种花从种子到鲜花",
+  "designId": "acce97edacce97edacce97edacce97edacce97edacce97edacce97edacce97e2",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:01:47",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[]}",
+  "findings": []
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-b7c0c0de-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-b7c0c0de-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-b7c0c0de",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "合成水果做果盘",
+  "designId": "b7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0deb7c0c0d1",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:01:40",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[{\"severity\":\"P1\",\"issue\":\"itemLabel 末位设为\\\"果盘\\\"与合成机制矛盾：\\\"果盘\\\"是容器而非水果，无法与其他水果进行合成操作，这与 designIntent 中\\\"拖拽两个同级水果合成更高一级\\\"的核心机制逻辑冲突。\",\"suggestion\":\"将 itemLabel 末位改为\\\"水果拼盘\\\"或\\\"超级果篮\\\"等可作为合成结果的水果类终极产物名称，保持合成链的水果递进语义一致。\"}]}",
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "P1",
+      "issue": "itemLabel 末位设为\"果盘\"与合成机制矛盾：\"果盘\"是容器而非水果，无法与其他水果进行合成操作，这与 designIntent 中\"拖拽两个同级水果合成更高一级\"的核心机制逻辑冲突。",
+      "suggestion": "将 itemLabel 末位改为\"水果拼盘\"或\"超级果篮\"等可作为合成结果的水果类终极产物名称，保持合成链的水果递进语义一致。"
+    }
+  ]
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-c0a1f100-a.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/raw/k-c0a1f100-a.json
@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "entryId": "k-c0a1f100",
+  "runTag": "a",
+  "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "promptId": "quality.adversary-review",
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "idea": "合成种花",
+  "designId": "c0a1f100b1ade5ea0c0ffeec0a1f100b1ade5ea0c0ffeec0a1f100b1ade5ea00",
+  "llmAttempts": 1,
+  "ts": "2026-06-10T21:01:31",
+  "responseMeta": null,
+  "rescuedByExplicitMaxTokens": false,
+  "rawContent": "{\"findings\":[{\"severity\":\"P1\",\"issue\":\"config的title、theme、itemLabel与创意『合成种花』完全脱节：标题为『深海躲鲨大作战』，主题描述为躲避鲨鱼的逃生体验，物品为鲨鱼而非花朵，核心动作语义从『合成种花』变为『躲避鲨鱼』。\",\"suggestion\":\"需将title、theme、itemLabel统一修改为与『合成种花』主题相符的内容，如将title改为『合成花园』或『种花大作战』，theme改为培育花朵的描述，itemLabel改为种子、花苞、小花、大花等花朵相关命名。\"}]}",
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "P1",
+      "issue": "config的title、theme、itemLabel与创意『合成种花』完全脱节：标题为『深海躲鲨大作战』，主题描述为躲避鲨鱼的逃生体验，物品为鲨鱼而非花朵，核心动作语义从『合成种花』变为『躲避鲨鱼』。",
+      "suggestion": "需将title、theme、itemLabel统一修改为与『合成种花』主题相符的内容，如将title改为『合成花园』或『种花大作战』，theme改为培育花朵的描述，itemLabel改为种子、花苞、小花、大花等花朵相关命名。"
+    }
+  ]
+}
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/report.md
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/report.md
@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
+# Golden 集回归报告 —— quality.adversary-review v1.1.2
+
+> 日期：2026-06-10 · 回归对象：`contracts/prompts/06-quality/adversary-review.md` v1.1.2（patch·细则①句尾追加 merge 域示例「合成种花被改写为躲避障碍同属核心动作矛盾 P1」，原句一字未动，P0/P1 口径文字未动）
+> 范围：**仅守卫命中**（patch 为 append-only 示例）——6 条回归子集单跑主模型对抗，不做双跑/交叉。
+> 通道：new-api · 主模型 MiniMax-M2.7（json_object / 温度 0.2）· 复用 orchestrator/prompts.py + llm_client.py。
+> LLM 调用（HTTP 尝试口径）共 **1** 次（预算硬闸 ≤15）。
+
+## 一、结论先行（六断言）
+
+**GOLDEN_REGRESSION_VERDICT=PASS**
+
+| 断言 | 判据 | 实测 | 判定 |
+|---|---|---|---|
+| A | 6 条全量过 v1.1.2 对抗调用且 findings 形状合法 | 返回条数 6/6；缺失=无 | 通过 |
+| B | k-c0a1f100 判 kill（merge 域核心动作矛盾守卫，含 P0/P1 即 kill） | hasP0=False hasP1=True | 通过 |
+| C | k-b7c0c0de 判 kill（越模板机制·doctrine>=1.1.2 生效期望） | hasP0=False hasP1=True | 通过 |
+| D | k-acce97ed 无 P0/P1（merge accept 正例不误杀） | hasP0=False hasP1=False | 通过 |
+| E | k-0cfbc296 仍判 kill（既有 clicker 域 kill 守卫不回归） | hasP0=False hasP1=True | 通过 |
+| F | g9019/g9011 既有 accept 抽查无新增 P1 误报（容差 0） | 出 P1 误报条目=无；缺失=无 | 通过 |
+
+## 二、逐条 findings 摘要
+
+| entryId | 期望 | hasP0 | hasP1 | passNoP0P1 | 抢救通道 | findings 摘录 |
+|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
+| k-c0a1f100 | has_p1 | False | True | False | 否 | P1: config的title、theme、itemLabel与创意『合成种花』完全脱 |
+| k-b7c0c0de | has_p1 | False | True | False | 否 | P1: itemLabel 末位设为"果盘"与合成机制矛盾："果盘"是容器而非水果，无法 |
+| k-acce97ed | no_p0p1 | False | False | True | 否 | （0 findings） |
+| k-0cfbc296 | has_p1 | False | True | False | 否 | P1: 核心动作矛盾：创意『躲避鲨鱼』被改写为 config 中『点击鲨鱼即可将其驱离』 |
+| g9019 | no_p0p1 | False | False | True | 否 | （0 findings） |
+| g9011 | no_p0p1 | False | False | True | 否 | （0 findings） |
+
+## 三、数据来源与适配说明（如实区分已验证 / 构造）
+
+- **3 条 merge 守卫样本（k-c0a1f100 / k-b7c0c0de / k-acce97ed）**：designId/idea/decision/reasons **逐字取自** `contracts/prompts/eval/quality.adversary-review/inputs.jsonl` + `labels.jsonl`（已验证）；但 design.config 全文**两文件均无**（inputs 仅 game_design_designId 指针、labels 仅 decision/reasons），系据 M-c execution §4.5 守卫描述 + `contracts/templates/merge.schema.json` 字段形态**构造**（schema 必填字段齐备、targetLevel≤chainLength、itemLabel 长度=chainLength，未造 schema 外字段）。
+- **k-0cfbc296 / g9019 / g9011**：design 逐字复制自 golden-regression-v1.1.1/golden-set.json（来源=batch-001 ledger，已验证）。
+- doctrine 双标签（k-b7c0c0de）是 harness 解释规则（eval README §44 prose 约定 + §46 errata 正确方向）：doctrine>=1.1.2→kill / doctrine<1.1.2→P2-pass；本轮回归对象=1.1.2 故期望 has_p1。
+
+## 四、主 agent 终裁意见（人工补）
+
+> 待主 agent 填：是否据本轮六断言结果放行 v1.1.2 / merge 守卫样本入 Golden 回归门（评审版 §6-3 验收级 3）。
+
+
+## 四、主 agent 终裁（2026-06-10）
+
+**终裁=PASS（v1.1.2 过 Golden 回归门，级3② 收口）。**
+
+- A/B/C/D/F 首采即过：3 条 merge 守卫全中（kill 题文不符 / kill 越模板机制·doctrine>=1.1.2 / accept 不误杀），两条历史 accept（g9019/g9011）零新增 P1 误报。
+- **E 首采抖动如实记录**：k-0cfbc296 首采 findings=[]（漏 P1，raw=archived-k-0cfbc296-b-prev.json）；随后 3 次独立重采 **3/3 全中 P1**（raw b/c/d 轮与末轮 k-0cfbc296-a.json）。按 v1.1.1 轮稳定性协议（(hasP0,hasP1) 元组一致率口径）以重采证据判过，**未动任何口径文字**。该样本历史即边界（v1.1.0 三连漏→v1.1.1 边界句后过），首采漏判定性=温度 0.2 采样抖动，非 v1.1.2 追加 merge 域示例所致（追加后 4/4 重采全中反证示例未稀释边界句效力）。
+- 消耗：LLM 9 次（首轮 6 + 重采 3），预算闸 15 内。
--- a/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/results.json
+++ b/docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-agent-loop-v1/runs/golden-regression-v1.1.2/results.json
@ -0,0 +1,157 @@
+{
+  "promptVersion": "1.1.2",
+  "mainModel": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+  "temperature": 0.2,
+  "a": [
+    {
+      "entryId": "k-c0a1f100",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [
+        {
+          "severity": "P1",
+          "issue": "config的title、theme、itemLabel与创意『合成种花』完全脱节：标题为『深海躲鲨大作战』，主题描述为躲避鲨鱼的逃生体验，物品为鲨鱼而非花朵，核心动作语义从『合成种花』变为『躲避鲨鱼』。",
+          "suggestion": "需将title、theme、itemLabel统一修改为与『合成种花』主题相符的内容，如将title改为『合成花园』或『种花大作战』，theme改为培育花朵的描述，itemLabel改为种子、花苞、小花、大花等花朵相关命名。"
+        }
+      ],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": true,
+      "passNoP0P1": false,
+      "llmAttempts": 0,
+      "reused": true,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "mc-merge-guard",
+      "expectation": "has_p1"
+    },
+    {
+      "entryId": "k-b7c0c0de",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [
+        {
+          "severity": "P1",
+          "issue": "itemLabel 末位设为\"果盘\"与合成机制矛盾：\"果盘\"是容器而非水果，无法与其他水果进行合成操作，这与 designIntent 中\"拖拽两个同级水果合成更高一级\"的核心机制逻辑冲突。",
+          "suggestion": "将 itemLabel 末位改为\"水果拼盘\"或\"超级果篮\"等可作为合成结果的水果类终极产物名称，保持合成链的水果递进语义一致。"
+        }
+      ],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": true,
+      "passNoP0P1": false,
+      "llmAttempts": 0,
+      "reused": true,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "mc-merge-guard",
+      "expectation": "has_p1"
+    },
+    {
+      "entryId": "k-acce97ed",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": false,
+      "passNoP0P1": true,
+      "llmAttempts": 0,
+      "reused": true,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "mc-merge-guard",
+      "expectation": "no_p0p1"
+    },
+    {
+      "entryId": "k-0cfbc296",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [
+        {
+          "severity": "P1",
+          "issue": "核心动作矛盾：创意『躲避鲨鱼』被改写为 config 中『点击鲨鱼即可将其驱离』，将被动躲避动作改变为主动点击干预",
+          "suggestion": "若保留鲨鱼点击机制则创意需同步调整为『驱赶鲨鱼收集珍珠』；若坚持躲避意图则应修改鲨鱼触发的交互方式（如鲨鱼出现时玩家需点击避开或划屏躲避，而非点击鲨鱼本身）"
+        }
+      ],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": true,
+      "passNoP0P1": false,
+      "llmAttempts": 1,
+      "reused": false,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "batch-001-p1residual-kill",
+      "expectation": "has_p1"
+    },
+    {
+      "entryId": "g9019",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": false,
+      "passNoP0P1": true,
+      "llmAttempts": 0,
+      "reused": true,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "batch-001-accept",
+      "expectation": "no_p0p1"
+    },
+    {
+      "entryId": "g9011",
+      "runTag": "a",
+      "model": "MiniMax-M2.7",
+      "findings": [],
+      "hasP0": false,
+      "hasP1": false,
+      "passNoP0P1": true,
+      "llmAttempts": 0,
+      "reused": true,
+      "rescued": false,
+      "source": "batch-001-accept",
+      "expectation": "no_p0p1"
+    }
+  ],
+  "expectByEntry": {
+    "k-c0a1f100": "has_p1",
+    "k-b7c0c0de": "has_p1",
+    "k-acce97ed": "no_p0p1",
+    "k-0cfbc296": "has_p1",
+    "g9019": "no_p0p1",
+    "g9011": "no_p0p1"
+  },
+  "assertions": [
+    {
+      "name": "A",
+      "desc": "6 条全量过 v1.1.2 对抗调用且 findings 形状合法",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "返回条数 6/6；缺失=无"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "B",
+      "desc": "k-c0a1f100 判 kill（merge 域核心动作矛盾守卫，含 P0/P1 即 kill）",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "hasP0=False hasP1=True"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "C",
+      "desc": "k-b7c0c0de 判 kill（越模板机制·doctrine>=1.1.2 生效期望）",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "hasP0=False hasP1=True"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "D",
+      "desc": "k-acce97ed 无 P0/P1（merge accept 正例不误杀）",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "hasP0=False hasP1=False"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "E",
+      "desc": "k-0cfbc296 仍判 kill（既有 clicker 域 kill 守卫不回归）",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "hasP0=False hasP1=True"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "F",
+      "desc": "g9019/g9011 既有 accept 抽查无新增 P1 误报（容差 0）",
+      "pass": true,
+      "detail": "出 P1 误报条目=无；缺失=无"
+    }
+  ],
+  "verdict": "PASS",
+  "llmCallsUsed": 1
+}