games-development-ai/wg1/gen-worker/calibration/report.json

{
  "stage": "stage1",
  "n_samples": 4,
  "anchor_note": "权威锚=创始人亲玩(2026-06-14)。原话:A 物理最好;B 第二;C 碰撞有明显问题;D 滑块每次点击只走一格、不符合玩家习惯。fun/verdict 由我把定性排序转成数值(创始人可再覆盖)。**重大发现:创始人排序推翻了我的自动判定**——我曾把 B(v2)判 objective-hollow、C(pro)判 best,均与亲玩相反。",
  "rows": [
    {
      "game_id": "breakout-flash-v3",
      "class": "good",
      "human": {
        "fun": 4,
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "创始人:物理最好(第1)。[原我标 basic=3,低估]",
        "anchor": "founder"
      },
      "vision": {
        "completeness": 4,
        "fun": 4,
        "problems": [
          "球起始位置在挡板正上方且初速向下时可能首帧直接掉出（边界条件虽通过测试，但首帧球贴在挡板附近略感不自然）",
          "砖块击碎反馈在截图中无法直接看到粒子（静态截图局限），但 F_wiring 显示粒子与音效调用正常"
        ],
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "经典打砖块实现到位：砖块网格、球反弹、挡板插值跟随、剩余砖数与分数实时变化（30→29、0→1），H_progress 门验证了核心机制真在跑，F_wiring 确认粒子+音效反馈真触发，E_live 15个不同状态说明动画与交互活跃——是款完整可玩、有反馈的休闲小品。"
      },
      "text": {
        "completeness": 5,
        "fun": 4,
        "problems": [],
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "经典打砖块，所有七门取证通过，核心循环完整且反馈到位，有实际进展和可玩性。"
      }
    },
    {
      "game_id": "breakout-pro",
      "class": "good",
      "human": {
        "fun": 2,
        "verdict": "fix",
        "note": "创始人:碰撞有明显问题。[原我+player 标 best=4,假阳性]",
        "anchor": "founder"
      },
      "vision": {
        "completeness": 4,
        "fun": 4,
        "problems": [
          "球在 after-play 中已落至挡板下方区域,可能存在穿透或漏判失败态的风险(球y位置约1400-垫子y约1700之间仍有空间,但需确认未漏detect death)",
          "部分橙色砖仍保留(剩余18)说明多次命中机制在工作,但after-play里球已经明显落在挡板下方飞,若该帧是终态前一刻则需验证 phase='gameover' 驻留契约",
          "首帧砖块整齐6×7布局 vs 玩后砖块被削去一大块,进度真实(15分对应15块),核心循环成立",
          "深色背景+亮色实心图形满足规格,无明显视觉缺陷"
        ],
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "经典打砖块,核心循环、粒子+音效反馈、多次命中变色、挡板角度反弹都到位,真进展,手感扎实。"
      },
      "text": {
        "completeness": 5,
        "fun": 4,
        "problems": [],
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "经典打砖块实现完整，粒子与音效反馈到位，操作流畅，胜负态明确，符合终态契约。"
      }
    },
    {
      "game_id": "breakout-flash-v2",
      "class": "good",
      "human": {
        "fun": 3,
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "创始人:第2、能玩。[原我标 objective-hollow=1,假阴性——盲打脚本没打到砖→误判空心]",
        "anchor": "founder"
      },
      "vision": {
        "completeness": 2,
        "fun": 2,
        "problems": [
          "H_progress 门未过：phase 始终为 booting，未按契约暴露 playing/gameover 状态",
          "终态契约未实现：球掉底应驻留 gameover 并显示 GAME OVER + 重玩提示，实际没有",
          "掉球后 phase 未切换，宿主轮询会漏判结束",
          "可玩回合太短：一次入场只打到 +1 分球就掉，体验未闭环"
        ],
        "verdict": "fix",
        "note": "砖块消除/粒子/音效/挡板移动都跑起来了，但终态契约完全没接——phase 锁在 booting，球掉底不切 gameover 不驻留，红线违规，必须修。"
      },
      "text": {
        "completeness": 1,
        "fun": 1,
        "problems": [
          "H_progress 未过，游戏未从 booting 切换到 playing 状态，核心循环未启动",
          "无任何游戏进展证据（分数、砖块、球运动等均为零）",
          "玩家无法操作或看到实质游戏内容，属于空心游戏"
        ],
        "verdict": "fix",
        "note": "运行数据表明游戏卡在 booting 状态，未进入 playing 阶段，无法进行任何游玩，必须修复状态机转换及可观测状态导出。"
      }
    },
    {
      "game_id": "breakout-m27",
      "class": "fix-control",
      "human": {
        "fun": 2,
        "verdict": "fix",
        "note": "创始人:滑块每次点击只走一格、不跟手(控制 bug,不符玩家习惯)",
        "anchor": "founder"
      },
      "vision": {
        "completeness": 3,
        "fun": 2,
        "problems": [
          "玩后截图 vs 首帧:Score 仍为 0、Bricks 仍为 24,球位置从右下移到左中但未撞击任何砖块/挡板/墙,无视觉反馈",
          "玩后砖块多出一行绿色(首帧 4 行红+橙,玩后 5 行红+橙+绿),首尾帧之间砖块数量/布局不一致,疑似关卡布局不稳定或随机化错误",
          "F_wiring 显示 487 次 synthSfx 调用,但 24 块砖一块没碎、0 分,音效调用与游戏事件严重脱钩(可能每帧 spam)",
          "缺少明显粒子/数字跳动/消除反馈,无 GAME OVER/YOU WIN 终态截图证据",
          "玩家全程只能看到一颗球在空荡中线附近漂,无爽点无反馈,体验空洞"
        ],
        "verdict": "fix",
        "note": "砖块未消除、分数零变化、玩后布局突变,核心循环虽存在但玩家视角下无进展,判定空心游戏待修。"
      },
      "text": {
        "completeness": 4,
        "fun": 4,
        "problems": [
          "终态phase驻留未在数据中直接验证，但七门通过暗示实现；缺少多次击中砖块的颜色变化证据"
        ],
        "verdict": "pass",
        "note": "游戏核心循环完整，有音效和粒子反馈，进度可感知，手感良好，基本符合Breakout玩法。"
      }
    }
  ],
  "metrics": {
    "vision": {
      "model": "MiniMax-M3",
      "fun_mae": 0.75,
      "verdict_match": "2/4",
      "hollow_rejected": "0/0",
      "hollow_false_green": "0/0",
      "good_accepted": "2/3",
      "gatekeeper_ok": false
    },
    "text": {
      "model": "deepseek-v4-flash",
      "fun_mae": 1.5,
      "verdict_match": "1/4",
      "hollow_rejected": "0/0",
      "hollow_false_green": "0/0",
      "good_accepted": "2/3",
      "gatekeeper_ok": false
    }
  },
  "cost": {
    "by_model": {
      "MiniMax-M3": {
        "in": 18939,
        "out": 1193,
        "rmb": 0.10385
      },
      "deepseek-v4-flash": {
        "in": 4810,
        "out": 1882,
        "rmb": 0.0071
      }
    },
    "total_rmb": 0.11095
  }
}