# 2026-09-01 创作链路合同校准提交前四维审查报告

verdict: PASS

## 审查范围

- `muse/sot/创作周期与Skill导读.md`
- `muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md`
- `muse/lifecycle/flow/chains/README.md`
- `muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/SKILL.md`
- `muse/lifecycle/context/skills/准备任务上下文/SKILL.md`
- `muse/技能目录.md`
- 实现补充核对：`muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py`
- 回显补充核对：`muse/authority/studio/read/server.py`
- 验证补充核对：`tests/skills/写下一章/test_gate_anchor_projection.py`、`muse/authority/studio/read/test_server_display.py`

排除项：`docs/实现回顾/技能身份中文化迁移实现回顾.md`、`muse/platform/llm/src/muse_llm.py`

## 逻辑完整性

- PASS：阶段 0 现在明确区分“前期多案候选”与“正式 `setting` Shadow”，退出条件不再自相矛盾；SoT 与场景 Skill 已对齐。[muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md:19](../muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md#L19) [muse/sot/创作周期与Skill导读.md:121](../muse/sot/创作周期与Skill导读.md#L121)
- PASS：节点 W 现在明确是“探索 → 回放 → 无工具生成”，不再把“来源优先级固定”误写成“全量预拼后直接喂给生成阶段”。[muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md:129](../muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md#L129) [muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md:173](../muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md#L173) [muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/SKILL.md:13](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/SKILL.md#L13)
- PASS：生产入口已把作品维度参数化到 CLI、运行编号、授权快照和门锚读取，不再只在入口层硬编码作品 12。[muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:16](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L16) [muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:259](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L259) [muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:304](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L304)

## 一致性

- PASS：`写下一章` 的目录描述、Skill 合同、链路登记和导读都统一为“两阶段写手”，不再同时出现“不得自行检索”和“探索阶段允许白名单只读工具”这组冲突表述。[muse/技能目录.md:63](../muse/技能目录.md#L63) [muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/SKILL.md:1](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/SKILL.md#L1) [muse/lifecycle/flow/chains/README.md:19](../muse/lifecycle/flow/chains/README.md#L19)
- PASS：raw 留痕口径统一为“PostgreSQL raw 表是正式留痕，仓外 raw vault 只是临时暂存或可选备份”，与数据权威域一致。[muse/lifecycle/context/skills/准备任务上下文/SKILL.md:63](../muse/lifecycle/context/skills/准备任务上下文/SKILL.md#L63) [muse/sot/domains/08-数据权威与可视化领域.md:70](../muse/sot/domains/08-数据权威与可视化领域.md#L70)
- PASS：只读看板的“改：”命令现在跟随当前运行/候选的作品与章节，不再把用户带回作品 12 第 3 章的旧入口口径。[muse/authority/studio/read/server.py:2489](../muse/authority/studio/read/server.py#L2489) [muse/authority/studio/read/test_server_display.py:94](../muse/authority/studio/read/test_server_display.py#L94)

## 合理性

- PASS：`DEFAULT_WORK_ID=12` 保留了既有样本兼容性，但新增 `--work-id` 和 `resolve_gate_requirements()`，避免破坏现有运行习惯，同时把作品切换收敛到显式参数。[muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:93](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L93) [muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:259](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L259)
- PASS：门锚仍按作品+章节显式登记，未把“样本常量”直接伪装成“所有作品通用规则”；文档把这一点保留为真实待建项，避免假完成。[muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py:113](../muse/content/work/skills/generate/写下一章/scripts/produce_next_chapter.py#L113) [muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md:271](../muse/sot/domains/05-创作流程领域.md#L271) [muse/sot/创作周期与Skill导读.md:662](../muse/sot/创作周期与Skill导读.md#L662)

## 可行性

- PASS：机械验证已覆盖改动落点。`skill_harness --strict` 通过；相关单测 40 条通过；架构测试 `test_author_instructions.py` 5 条、`test_markdown_links.py` 2 条、`test_skills_index.py` 3 条通过；`skills_index.py --check` 通过；`git diff --check` 通过。
- PASS：新增测试直接覆盖了作品级门锚解析与看板重产命令回填，说明本次修复不是只改文档。[tests/skills/写下一章/test_gate_anchor_projection.py:38](../tests/skills/写下一章/test_gate_anchor_projection.py#L38) [muse/authority/studio/read/test_server_display.py:94](../muse/authority/studio/read/test_server_display.py#L94)

## 残余待建

- 门锚还没有从细纲或正式规划中自动派生，仍需按作品+章节登记；未登记即失败关闭。这是保留的真实边界，不构成阻断本次提交。
- 章后抽取异步执行、方法 Skill 自动只读检查、结构化 `style` 八字段抽取仍待建，文档已明确保留。