oh-my-muse/docs/agent-specs/.agent

# docs/agent-specs

用途：存放 P1R 等跨模块 agent 规格与执行计划文档。

边界：本目录只记录审阅版、执行版、review gate 与交接约束，不承载代码实现，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner 或 coverage 口径。

> 归档说明(2026-06-20)：P1R 解锁(审阅版/执行版)与 agent 基建交付等**已完成阶段文档**已移至 [`docs/archive/`](../archive/README.md)；下文 P1R-7b 历史记述中提到的这些路径均以归档副本为准。本目录现仅留：现状基线、对抗复盘、P0 冻结令(知识网根基)与 meta-schema 当前文档。人读全局见 [`docs/项目功能与进度总览.md`](../项目功能与进度总览.md)。**下文出现的覆盖数(`completed=100/127/147`、`needsVerification=133/86` 等)均为 P1R 各阶段历史快照,当前接口覆盖门口径以覆盖 JSON(233/233)/主台账为准。**

当前状态：P1R-7b 执行版已作为全局方案下的 AI 子计划通过 fresh spec re-review（Erdos）和 fresh quality/feasibility review（Carver）。Task 1 只读 preflight 已双 PASS（Ramanujan / Descartes），Task 2 migration/schema 已双 PASS（Boyle / Lorentz），Task 3 AI DO/Mapper/Service 与 terminal fact 同事务 outbox 已双 PASS（Wegener / Bohr），Task 4 AI worker / dispatcher 已在修复 spec review FAIL 后双 PASS（Hume / Linnaeus）。Task 4 focused evidence 为 Worker tests=20、Mapper tests=5，均 failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0；残余非阻塞风险包括 worker 默认开关口径、retryable 状态日志、terminalFact 与 outbox 完整一致性后续加固。Task 5 focused E2E 已由 Task 5a done 可见性和 Task 5b error / duplicate / rejected 证据合并收口，并通过 fresh spec review（Ptolemy）与 fresh quality/feasibility review（Curie）双 PASS；本地 evidence 为 `P1rAiEventsPublishEndToEndTest` tests=4、failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0，覆盖 done owner 可见与跨 owner 不可见、error payload 不泄露敏感 detail、duplicate replay 同 eventId/sequenceNo、rejected -> outbox dead_letter 且 visible query 为空。该证据仍是 focused harness，不代表 P1R-7b completed，也不代表 Events/Market completed。Task 6 曾因 coverage scanner `--check` 会重写受保护 coverage JSON/Markdown 而 BLOCKED；该 diff 已按受保护边界回退，当前 protected diff 为空。执行版修订 spec review（Feynman）FAIL：Task 7 仍直跑 scanner，Market 命令只看 completionStatus；spec re-review（Banach）FAIL：Task 6 Market 命令仍只看 completionStatus。已修复为 Task 6/Task 7 都在临时隔离副本运行 scanner，当前 worktree protected diff 必须为空，并用 `implementationStatus/completionStatus` 验证 Market 为 `dedicated/needs_verification 32`；修订方案 fresh spec re-review（Kuhn）PASS、fresh quality/feasibility review（Meitner）PASS。Task 6 revised gate 由 fresh implementer（Lorentz）DONE，本轮无文件改动；evidence 为 dependency test 2/2、P1R focused gates 29/29、Migration SQL 4/4、Flyway `_test` 4/4 均 failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0；隔离副本 scanner exit 0，summary 为 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0；Events `streamEvents=dedicated/needs_verification`，Market 32 个 operation 均为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；dependency tree 证明 AI server 依赖 events-api、不依赖 events-server，Events server 不反向依赖 AI/Knowledge/Market/Member/Content server。下一步必须 fresh Task 6 spec review，未双 PASS 前不能进入 Task 7。

最新补记：Task 6 spec review（Ohm）PASS，但指出 dependency test 未显式覆盖 `muse-module-content-server` 属于依赖合同完整性风险；按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 处理后判定该反馈有效。fresh implementer（Peirce）已把 `P1rAiEventsPublishDependencyTest` forbidden source owner server 列表补齐为 AI / Knowledge / Market / Member / Content，并运行 dependency test 2/2 通过，protected diff 为空。controller 随后重跑 P1R focused gates 29/29 通过；再以 `/tmp/p1r7b-coverage-scan.N0QGvX` 临时隔离副本运行 scanner `--check` exit 0，summary 仍为 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0，Events 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`，Market 32 个 operation 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`，当前真实 worktree 保护文件 diff 为空。只读检索 `docs/memorys` 证实 P1R-7a 留痕已把 source owner propagation 明确移入 P1R-7b，且 P1R-7a / Events / Market 均不得写成 completed。执行版文档已同步修正 Task 6 与数据流段的依赖合同旧口径，统一为 Events server 不反向依赖 AI / Knowledge / Market / Member / Content server。由于测试和执行版文档均有变更，下一步必须重新派发 fresh Task 6 spec review；未双 PASS 前不能进入 Task 7。

Task 6 复审收口：fresh spec compliance review（Huygens）PASS，阻塞项无；其已验证 Content forbidden、执行版旧口径清空、P1R focused gates 29 个 surefire evidence、隔离 scanner evidence、Events/Market 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。fresh quality/feasibility review（Boyle）PASS，阻塞项无；其已验证 dependency test 的 XML 安全解析、仓库根查找、direct dependency 机械断言、Content 补充不会误禁 AI 既有 Content 依赖、`/tmp` 隔离 scanner 方案可行、dependency / coverage / migration gate 证据链相互独立。非阻塞风险：dependency test 只覆盖 direct POM dependencies，后续 full verification 仍应保留 `dependency:tree`；Task 7 或最终 gate 前需 controller 继续在 `/tmp` 隔离副本重跑 scanner 并确认 protected diff 为空。Task 6 当前可视为双 PASS 完成；仍不代表 P1R-7b completed、Events completed 或 Market completed。

Task 7 preflight 修订：执行版最终验证命令原先把 `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests` 放在测试与 scanner 之后，存在清除 `target/surefire-reports` 导致最终无法证明 test count > 0 的顺序风险。已修订为先运行 reactor build，再运行 focused tests / P1R gates / Flyway / scanner，并要求最终保留 surefire XML 证据。该修订只影响执行版验证顺序，不修改实现代码、OpenAPI、scanner 或 coverage 报告。

Task 7 fresh implementer 最终验证：状态 `DONE`，仅代表 P1R-7b AI source owner propagation evidence 推进到 `needs_verification` 证据层，不代表 Events / P1R-7 / Market completed。工作区 `/Users/qingse/.config/superpowers/worktrees/oh-my-muse/dev-1.0.0`，分支 `dev/1.0.0`。Reactor build 已按修订顺序先运行：`mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true -pl muse-server -am` exit 0，47/47 reactor modules success。AI/Events focused tests exit 0，surefire XML 计数为 `MuseAiEventPublishOutboxMapperTest` 5、`MuseAiEventPublishOutboxServiceTest` 11、`MuseAiEventPublishWorkerTest` 20、`MuseAiRuntimeProjectionServiceTest` 5、`MuseJobServiceTest` 25、`EventsPublishServiceTest` 17、`EventsStreamServiceTest` 9，全部 failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0。P1R mixed gates exit 0，`P1rAiEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest` 4、`P1rAiEventsPublishDependencyTest` 2、`P1rAiEventsPublishEndToEndTest` 4、`P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 5、`P1rEventsRealApiGateTest` 5、`P1rEventsRouteOwnershipTest` 4、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest` 6、`P1rAiRouteOwnershipTest` 7，全部 failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0。Flyway `_test` 使用 `muse_p1r7b_events_publish_test`，命令包含 `flyway.postgresql.transactional.lock=false` 与 `p1r.flyway.locations=filesystem:sql/muse`，`P1rAiEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` tests=4、failures=0/errors=0/skipped=0，migrations_executed=17、target_schema_version=17、v17_table=`muse_ai_event_publish_outbox`。dependency tree gate：AI server 有 `muse-module-events-api:compile`，显式探针输出 `AI_EVENTS_SERVER_ABSENT`；Events server source owner forbidden 探针输出 `EVENTS_FORBIDDEN_SOURCE_OWNER_ABSENT`。coverage scanner 仅在 `/tmp/p1r7b-final-coverage-scan.AoKcDl` 隔离副本运行，exit 0，summary 为 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0；Events `streamEvents=dedicated/needs_verification`，Market 32 个 operation 均为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。初始与最终 protected status/diff 均为空。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-06-P1R7bSourceOwnerPropagation真实链路.md`。下一步必须 fresh Task 7 spec review + fresh Task 7 quality/feasibility review；未双 PASS 前不能最终收口、提交、push 或推进 completed。

Task 7 复审收口：fresh spec compliance review（Mencius）PASS，阻塞项无；其已验证 Task 7 最终验证范围、16 个目标测试类 surefire XML、Flyway `_test` 参数、隔离 coverage 副本、protected diff、memory 与 `.agent` 的 needs_verification/completed 边界。fresh quality/feasibility review（Hume）PASS，阻塞项无；其已验证 memory 质量、fact/inference/assumption 分离、`mvn clean install` 前置顺序、surefire XML 留存、Flyway `_test` 证据、隔离 scanner、dependency tree gate 和核心实现/测试覆盖。非阻塞建议：dependency tree 原始输出未单独保存为 artifact，后续提交/最终交接可保留三条 dependency tree 命令和关键输出；双 PASS 后仍不得自动提交、push 或推进 Events / P1R-7 / Market completed，必须等待用户明确批准提交边界与 completed approval。

P1R-7b 已按逻辑拆分提交并 push 到 `origin/dev/1.0.0`：`3db5fbe feat(p1r): 接入 AI 事件传播真实链路`、`230152c test(p1r): 收口 AI 事件传播真实链路门禁`。当前分支已与远端对齐到 `230152c`。下一主线进入 P1R-7c Knowledge Source Owner Propagation 审阅版，目标只做 Knowledge source status / projection summary 的用户可见 Events notification 方案审阅，不实现代码、不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage、不推进 completed。只读盘点事实：Knowledge server 当前无 `muse-module-events-api` 依赖；已有 `muse_knowledge_source_event`、`muse_knowledge_source_binding_projection`、`muse_knowledge_projection_task`；`MuseKnowledgeSourceEventService` 当前在事务内写 source event、同步更新 projection，并将 projection task 明确写为 `completed`，注释说明避免制造无执行者的 queued task；当前没有 Knowledge publish outbox、claim/retry/dead-letter worker 或 `FOR UPDATE SKIP LOCKED` 领取语义。P1R-7c 审阅版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-06-P1R7cKnowledgeSourceOwnerPropagation审阅版.md`，推荐新增独立 Knowledge Events publish outbox，使用 Events 现有 `notification` event type，禁止复用 projection task 作为发布队列，禁止发布知识资料原文、RAGFlow raw、GraphRAG trace、授权快照或敏感 reason。下一步必须 fresh spec compliance review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 后才允许写执行版。

P1R-7c 审阅版首轮 review：security reviewer（Leibniz）PASS、scope reviewer（Locke）PASS；quality/feasibility reviewer（Darwin）FAIL、adversarial reviewer（Kierkegaard）FAIL，阻塞项同源：首批 Knowledge 事件与现有 source event 写入模型不闭合。已按 `receiving-code-review` 验证该反馈有效：`MuseKnowledgeSourceEventDO` 没有顶层 `eventType` / `affectedTargets`，`MuseKnowledgeAccessPolicyService`、`MuseKnowledgeBaseService`、`MuseKnowledgeDocumentService` 直接构造 source event 的 summary/status/actionPolicy 形态不统一，其中 `enableGlobalKnowledgeBase` 当前不写 source event。审阅版已修订为只覆盖 `MuseKnowledgeSourceEventService.triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent` canonical source status / projection summary 链路，明确排除 AccessPolicy/Base/Document 直接写 source event 入口到后续标准化切片；notification type 固定使用 Events 已声明的 `source_status_change`；payload 合同改为 DO 顶层 allowlist + canonical `eventSummary` / projection summary allowlist，并默认不写 `resourceRef`。旧 spec reviewer（Carson）因基于过期文档仍在运行，已关闭。下一步需对修订后的审阅版重新派发 fresh spec compliance review + fresh quality/feasibility review；未双 PASS 前不能写执行版、实现代码、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7c 审阅版第二轮 review：fresh spec compliance reviewer（Maxwell）FAIL、fresh quality/feasibility reviewer（Bohr）FAIL，阻塞项同源：canonical `triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent` 当前写 `MuseKnowledgeSourceEventDO.ownerUserId=0`，而 Events SSE visible query 按登录用户 `ownerUserId` 过滤；如果直接用 source event 顶层 owner 发布，普通用户不可见。已验证反馈有效：`UnifiedEventMapper.selectVisibleEventsForOwner` 按 tenantId、ownerUserId、accepted、deleted=false、visibleFrom、sequenceNo 过滤；`muse_knowledge_source_binding_projection` 有 `owner_user_id`、`work_id`、`kb_id`、`binding_id`、`last_event_id` 和 owner/source/kb 唯一约束，可作为 affected owner fan-out 来源。审阅版已修订为 P1R-7c 采用 per affected owner notification：source event owner `0` 只保留为 global source fact owner，outbox 创建必须在 `triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent` 同事务内按更新后的 binding projection owner 去重 fan-out，排除 null/0 owner；每个 target owner 独立 outbox/worker/retry/dead_letter；Events commandId/source tuple 必须包含 sourceEventId + targetOwnerUserId，避免 V16 source tuple/command 唯一约束跨 owner 撞车。下一步需第三轮 fresh spec compliance review + fresh quality/feasibility review；未双 PASS 前不能写执行版、实现代码、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7c 审阅版第三轮 review 已双 PASS：fresh spec compliance reviewer（Parfit）PASS、fresh quality/feasibility reviewer（Aquinas）PASS，阻塞项无。Parfit 已验证：审阅版只覆盖 Knowledge source owner propagation，不进入 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed；第一批只覆盖 `MuseKnowledgeSourceEventService.triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent` canonical 入口并排除 AccessPolicy/Base/Document 直接 source event 写入入口；per affected owner fan-out 已与 Events visible query 和 V16 command/source tuple 唯一约束闭合；OpenAPI/scanner/coverage 未被要求修改。Aquinas 已验证：canonical 入口同事务 source event / projection / projection task 链路与 outbox fan-out 兼容；owner `0` 不直接用于 SSE；`notification/source_status_change` 复用现有合同；Knowledge 仅允许依赖 events-api，不依赖 events-server；projection task 仍不是 publish worker；后续 mapper、migration、worker、E2E、retry/dead_letter、Flyway `_test`、隔离 coverage scanner 都已作为执行版必含 gate。下一步可以编写 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-06-P1R7cKnowledgeSourceOwnerPropagation执行版.md`；执行版完成后仍需 fresh spec + quality 双 review，之后才可实现。不得提交、push 或推进 completed，除非用户另行明确批准。

P1R-7c 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-06-P1R7cKnowledgeSourceOwnerPropagation执行版.md`。该执行版继承 Parfit/Aquinas 双 PASS 后的审阅方案，锁定 canonical `triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent`、per affected projection owner fan-out、Knowledge 本域 `muse_knowledge_event_publish_outbox`、V18 migration、Knowledge worker 调用 `EventsPublishApi`、`notification/source_status_change` payload allowlist、dependency gate、Flyway `_test`、E2E 和隔离 coverage scanner。执行版同时明确：source event `ownerUserId=0` 只代表 global source fact owner，不能直接用于 SSE 可见 owner；`document_deleted`、AccessPolicy/Base/Document 直接 source event 写入入口、RAGFlow/GraphRAG raw、知识正文或 chunk 不进入 P1R-7c 第一批。当前没有实现代码改动，没有 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report 改动。下一步必须派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能实现代码、提交、push 或推进 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed。

P1R-7c 执行版首轮 quality/feasibility review（Sartre）FAIL，两个 P1 blocker 已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 只读验证为有效：其一，执行版 mixed gate 误包含 P1R-5/V14 专用 `P1rKnowledgeFlywayMigrationIT`，该测试固定 target V14 且需要独立 Flyway 参数，新增 V18 后不应混入 P1R-7c gate；其二，执行版要求 invalid owner 进入 `dead_letter`，但 V18 DDL 同时要求 `target_owner_user_id NOT NULL` 且 `>0`，合同不闭合。执行版已修订：P1R mixed gate 移除旧 `P1rKnowledgeFlywayMigrationIT` 并加 `-am`，V18 真实 Flyway 证据只来自新增 `P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT`；invalid owner 改为 fan-out 阶段过滤并记录安全日志/审计摘要，不创建 outbox、不发布 owner 0、不要求 dead_letter 行；同时补充 outbox service 写入前必须把空 `sourceRevision` 归一化为 Events 现有 `__none__`。由于执行版已在 review 后变更，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；首轮 Sartre 不能计入 PASS gate。

P1R-7c 执行版第二轮 spec compliance review（Chandrasekhar）FAIL，P1 blocker 已只读验证有效：执行版 mixed gate 仍包含 `P1rKnowledgeRuntimeEndToEndLiveAcceptanceIT`，该测试是 P1R-5 Knowledge/RAGFlow opt-in live acceptance，启用时迁移到 V14 并外呼真实 RAGFlow，不能作为 P1R-7c Knowledge Events publish required gate。执行版已修订：P1R mixed gate 移除 `P1rKnowledgeRuntimeEndToEndLiveAcceptanceIT`；旧 `P1rKnowledgeFlywayMigrationIT` 与 `P1rKnowledgeRuntimeEndToEndLiveAcceptanceIT` 均明确不得计入 P1R-7c required PASS gate，后者如需发布前回归只能单列为 P1R-5 optional external regression。由于执行版再次变更，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；第二轮 Chandrasekhar 不能计入 PASS gate，第二轮 Nash 已关闭为 stale。

P1R-7c 执行版第三轮 spec compliance review（Curie）PASS，但随后 quality/feasibility review（Hooke）FAIL，Curie PASS 因后续文档修订失效，不能计入最终 PASS gate。Hooke 的三个 P1 已只读验证并修订：第一，执行版写了继续运行 Events/AI gate，但 mixed gate 命令缺 AI gate，已补回 `P1rAiRealApiGateTest` 与 `P1rAiRouteOwnershipTest`，并明确除非触碰 AI outbox/worker 或 Events publish 公共合同，否则不重跑 `P1rAiEventsPublish*` 三个 gate；第二，invalid owner fan-out 审计摘要缺少可实现数据路径，已新增 `selectFanoutOwnerAuditSummaryByLastEventId` mapper 合同，并把 `ownerFanoutSummary` 明确写入 `muse_knowledge_projection_task.result_summary`，包含 total/valid/invalid/distinct/queued 计数；第三，worker 回滚策略要求配置关闭但未定义配置，已新增 `muse.knowledge.events.publish-worker.enabled=false` 默认关闭、scheduled delay 配置键、disabled 不 claim / enabled 才 claim focused test 要求。审阅版也同步修正 invalid owner 旧 dead_letter 口径为“过滤+审计摘要+安全日志，不创建 outbox”。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；第三轮 Curie/Hooke 不能作为最终双 PASS。

P1R-7c 执行版第四轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：spec compliance reviewer（Bernoulli）PASS，quality/feasibility reviewer（Hilbert）PASS，阻塞项无。Bernoulli 已验证：执行版继承审阅版核心边界，只覆盖 `MuseKnowledgeSourceEventService.triggerGlobalKBSourceEvent`，不覆盖 AccessPolicy/Base/Document 直接 source event 入口，不推进 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed；旧 P1R-5/V14 Flyway 与 live acceptance gate 均已排除；invalid owner 合同、owner fan-out、Events visible query、V16 command/source tuple、依赖方向与 V18 migration 前提闭合；protected diff 为空。Hilbert 已验证：Knowledge source event/projection 现有字段支撑 fan-out；Events publish 支持 `notification/source_status_change` 和 `__none__`；AI P1R-7b outbox/worker 模式可复用到 Knowledge；当前执行版覆盖 happy/empty/invalid owner/rejected/retryable/dead_letter/worker enabled gate。非阻塞风险：实现时需证明 fan-out mapper 的 tenant 限定，`blocked` 只作为 Events publish 兼容返回分支测试，same source event + owner replay 应覆盖同一 outbox retry 而不是重新触发随机 source event。双 PASS 后可以进入实现，但仍不得修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report，不得推进 completed，不得提交或 push，除非用户另行明确批准。

P1R-7c implementation evidence 当前状态：Knowledge source owner propagation 主体实现、V18 SQL、server/framework/api gates 与 focused tests 已落地；最初 V18 Flyway `_test` 因 Java 全局 `socksProxyHost/http.proxyHost/https.proxyHost=127.0.0.1:7897` 导致 PostgreSQL JDBC 连接 EOF。已通过 A/B 探针验证同一 JDBC URL 默认代理失败、清空 JVM 代理属性成功；随后使用 `-Djava.net.useSystemProxies=false -DsocksProxyHost= -DsocksProxyPort= -Dhttp.proxyHost= -Dhttp.proxyPort= -Dhttps.proxyHost= -Dhttps.proxyPort=` 重跑 `P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 全量 3 tests PASS。新增实现包括 Knowledge server 直接依赖 `muse-module-events-api`、`MuseKnowledgeEventPublishOutboxDO/Mapper/Service/Worker`、`MuseKnowledgeEventsProperties` 默认 `muse.knowledge.events.publish-worker.enabled=false`、`MuseKnowledgeSourceEventService` 在 canonical source event 事务内创建 per target owner outbox 并把 `ownerFanoutSummary` 写入 projection task summary、`MuseKnowledgeSourceBindingProjectionMapper` fan-out target 与 audit summary 查询、`V18__extend_knowledge_events_publish_outbox.sql`。测试 evidence：Knowledge focused tests `MuseKnowledgeEventPublishOutboxServiceTest,MuseKnowledgeEventPublishWorkerTest,MuseKnowledgeSourceEventServiceTest` 更新为 14/14 pass；P1R mixed executable gates `P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest,P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishDependencyTest,P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishEndToEndTest,P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRouteOwnershipTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRouteOwnershipTest` 更新为 37/37 pass；`P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 更新为 3/3 pass，输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=18`、`successful_migration_count=18`、`target_schema_version=18`、`v18_table=muse_knowledge_event_publish_outbox`。full reactor `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true` 为 62/62 modules success；coverage scanner 在 `/tmp/p1r7c-clean-coverage-scan.fA1ZHI` 隔离副本运行 exit 0；真实 worktree protected OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 为空。仍不得修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report，不得推进 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed。

P1R-7c implementation fresh review 派发结果：Sagan correctness review PASS，Dalton testing evidence review PASS，Halley data integrity review FAIL。Halley 的有效 P1 为 outbox claim 后 `markPublished/markRetryable/markDeadLetter` 只按 id + tenant 回写，缺少“本次 claim 所有权”保护，过期 worker 可能覆盖新 claim 的 published / retryable / dead_letter 终态。已按 TDD 修复：先新增 `MuseKnowledgeEventPublishWorkerTest.should_guardTerminalStatusUpdatesWithClaimAttemptOwnership`，RED 失败信息为 `markPublished 必须只允许当前 running claim 回写终态`；随后把 mapper 三类终态回写补为 `publish_status='running' AND attempt_count=#{claimedAttemptCount}`，worker 调用传入 claim 返回的 `attemptCount`，并在 `P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishEndToEndTest` 增加 stale claim terminal update 被忽略的 focused E2E。修复后验证：`MuseKnowledgeEventPublishWorkerTest` 7/7 pass，Knowledge focused tests 更新为 14/14 pass，P1R mixed executable gates 更新为 37/37 pass。Flyway `_test` blocker 也已通过禁用 JVM 代理参数关闭为 3/3 pass。由于 claim ownership 与 Flyway IT 断言均在 review 后修改，下一步仍需要重新派发 fresh implementation spec review + quality/feasibility review；仍不得推进 completed。

P1R-7c 修复后 fresh review 第一轮：Kuhn correctness/spec review PASS，Herschel data integrity review PASS；均明确 PASS 只代表 `needs_verification` evidence 可收口，不代表 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed。Herschel 提出两个 P2 非阻塞建议：其一，`singleLiteralCheck` 只做 substring，未来可能误接受 `event_type='notification' OR ...`；其二，worker 对终态 update 返回 0 缺少 stale claim 诊断日志。已按 `receiving-code-review` 验证为有效且局部可修，并按 TDD 处理：新增 `P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT.should_rejectBroadSingleLiteralConstraintExpression` 先 RED，随后将 `singleLiteralCheck` 改为精确单表达式匹配；新增真实 PostgreSQL 负向 insert 约束探针，验证 event_type、notification_type、publish_status、target_owner_user_id check 真实拒绝非法行；新增 `MuseKnowledgeEventPublishWorkerTest.should_logWhenAcceptedTerminalUpdateIsSkippedByStaleClaim` 先 RED，随后 worker 对 `markPublished/markRetryable/markDeadLetter` 返回 0 记录包含 tenantId、targetOwnerUserId、outboxId、sourceEventId、attempt、targetStatus、errorCode 的 warning。RED/GREEN 事实：两个新增测试均先按预期失败；修复后 Flyway 纯函数测试 1/1 pass，worker stale-claim 日志测试 1/1 pass。一次并行 Maven 验证因两个命令同时触碰 Knowledge `target`，出现源码/target class 瞬时不一致导致 testCompile 找不到已存在类；串行重跑 worker 测试通过，故该失败判定为并发构建污染，不作为代码缺陷。由于 P2 修复包含生产 worker 日志行为变更与 Flyway IT 测试增强，Kuhn/Herschel 双 PASS 不能作为最后一笔 review；下一步必须重跑 focused/mixed/Flyway/coverage/protected diff，并重新派发窄口 fresh implementation review。仍不得修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report，不得推进 completed。

P1R-7c P2 增强后最终收口：controller 已重跑 full reactor `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true`，62/62 modules success；随后串行重跑 Knowledge focused tests 15/15 pass、P1R mixed executable gates 37/37 pass、`P1rKnowledgeEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 4/4 pass，V18 输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=18`、`target_schema_version=18`、`v18_table=muse_knowledge_event_publish_outbox`；coverage scanner 仅在 `/tmp/p1r7c-final-coverage-scan.2HXo1Z` 隔离副本运行 exit 0，summary 保持 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0，Events `streamEvents=dedicated/needs_verification`，Market 32 个 operation 均为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；真实 worktree 受保护 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 为空。P2 后 fresh review 已双 PASS：Rawls correctness/spec review PASS，Boole data-integrity/testing review PASS；两者均明确该结论只代表 Knowledge source owner propagation evidence 收口到 `needs_verification`，不代表 Events/P1R-7/Knowledge/Market completed。下一步可按逻辑分组准备提交；提交、push 或任何 completed 推进仍需用户明确批准。

P1R-7c 已按逻辑拆分提交并 push 到 `origin/dev/1.0.0`：`cef686b feat(p1r): 接入 Knowledge 事件传播真实链路`、`e55618f test(p1r): 收口 Knowledge 事件传播真实链路门禁`。当前分支已与远端对齐到 `e55618f`，worktree 干净，protected OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 为空。下一主线进入 P1R-7d Market Source Owner Propagation 审阅版，目标只做 Market governance/source status 的用户可见 Events notification 方案审阅，不实现代码、不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage、不推进 completed。只读盘点事实：Events OpenAPI 已声明 `notification/governance_action`；`AdminMarketGovernanceServiceImpl` 在 `delistAsset`/`recallAsset` 成功后写 `muse_market_governance_action`，`recallAsset` 还写 `muse_market_source_status_event` 且 `needs_recheck` 只进入 actionPolicy/recheckReasons；`MarketAccountProjectionOutboxService` 当前只表达 Market -> Member Account 投影同步状态，没有 Events publish claim/retry/dead_letter worker；handoff 涉及 token hash、授权摘要和目标 owner，不进入第一切片。P1R-7d 审阅版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-07-P1R7dMarketSourceOwnerPropagation审阅版.md`，推荐新增独立 Market Events publish outbox，复用 Events 现有 `notification/governance_action`，禁止复用 Account projection outbox，禁止发布授权快照、handoff token、管理员内部备注原文、完整 actionSnapshot 或 target owner 私有事实。下一步必须 fresh spec compliance review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 后才允许写执行版。

P1R-7d 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Ptolemy spec compliance PASS、Galileo quality/feasibility PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。P3 已纳入执行版：`recall` 第一切片只发布一条 `market_governance_action` notification，`muse_market_source_status_event` 只作为事实旁证和后续扩展点；`resourceRef.resourceId` 必须是数值型；command replay 不补历史 outbox；实现必须由 fresh implementer 执行，完成后再做 fresh spec review 与 fresh quality/feasibility review。P1R-7d 执行版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-07-P1R7dMarketSourceOwnerPropagation执行版.md`，锁定 V19 `muse_market_event_publish_outbox`、Market server 只依赖 events-api、worker 默认 disabled、claim attempt ownership、stale terminal update 日志、focused/mixed/Flyway `_test`/隔离 coverage scanner/protected diff gate。当前仍没有实现代码改动，没有 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report 改动，不得推进 Events/P1R-7/Market completed。下一步必须 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现或提交。

P1R-7d 执行版首轮 quality/feasibility review（Faraday）FAIL，P1 blocker 已验证有效：worktree 根目录没有 `pom.xml`，reactor POM 位于 `muse-cloud/pom.xml`，执行版最终验证命令若在 worktree 根直接运行 Maven/Flyway 会失败。已修订执行版：Task 0 明确 Git/protected diff/coverage scanner 在 worktree 根执行，Maven/Flyway 必须先 `cd muse-cloud`；最终验证 1-4 步命令均补 `cd muse-cloud`；同时补充 `EventsPublishReqDTO.resourceId` 仍为字符串，`payloadSummary.resourceRef.resourceId` 必须保持 Number/Long 语义并分别测试。旧 spec reviewer（Avicenna）已关闭，首轮 review 不计入 PASS gate。由于执行版已修改，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第二轮 quality/feasibility review（Hume）FAIL，两个 P1 与一个 P2 已验证有效：Worker `CommonResult error` 路径虽在失败路径合同中要求 retryable/dead_letter，但 Task 6 未要求测试；payload 禁发字段列表比 Task 6 负断言更宽，缺 exact allowlist 测试；最终验证命令用连续 `cd muse-cloud` 代码块时可能在同一 shell 下目录漂移。旧 spec reviewer（Lovelace）已关闭，第二轮 review 不计入 PASS gate。执行版已修订：payload 顶层 exact allowlist 固定为 `type/message/resourceRef/timestamp`，`resourceRef` exact allowlist 固定为 `resourceType/resourceId`；Task 6 补齐 authorization snapshot / handoff token / target owner / admin note / error stack / requestHash 负断言；Task 6 补 CommonResult error 非最后一次 -> retryable、最后一次 -> dead_letter，并要求 lastError 只保存安全摘要；V19 migration 清单和 SQL gate 补 update_time trigger；最终验证 1-4 步改成绝对路径 `cd /Users/qingse/.config/superpowers/worktrees/oh-my-muse/dev-1.0.0/muse-cloud && ...`。由于执行版再次修改，下一步必须第三轮 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第三轮 spec compliance review（Cicero）FAIL，P1 blocker 已验证有效：全局执行版要求每个 owner 子计划必须包含 Maven dependency tree 验证命令，当前 P1R-7d 执行版只包含 dependency test 和 mixed gate，缺 dependency tree 原始证据命令。第三轮 feasibility reviewer（Bacon）已关闭，不计入 PASS gate。执行版已修订：最终验证新增 Dependency tree gate，要求 Market server dependency tree 明确包含 `muse-module-events-api`，证明 Market server 不依赖 `muse-module-events-server`、Events server 不反向依赖 AI/Knowledge/Market/Member/Content server；命令将原始 tree 输出写入 `/tmp/p1r7d-market-server-dependency-tree.txt` 与 `/tmp/p1r7d-events-server-dependency-tree.txt`，再用 `rg` 正向/反向断言，避免 Maven 失败被管道吞掉；完成条件同步补 `dependency tree` gate。由于执行版再次修改，下一步必须第四轮 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第四轮 spec compliance review（Mendel）FAIL，P1/P2 已验证有效：执行版 mixed gate 未继承审阅版要求的 AI 已有 source owner gates，缺 `P1rAiEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest` / `P1rAiEventsPublishDependencyTest` / `P1rAiEventsPublishEndToEndTest`；payload invalid fail-closed 缺固定错误码；最终 Protected diff 步骤未内联命令。第四轮 feasibility reviewer（Huygens）已关闭，不计入 PASS gate。执行版已修订：mixed gate 列表与最终命令补 AI EventsPublish 三个 gate，并保留 Knowledge EventsPublish gates；payload invalid 固定错误码为 `MARKET_EVENTS_PAYLOAD_INVALID`，Task 6 要求断言只进入安全日志或安全 lastError 摘要、不创建 outbox、不发布；Protected diff 步骤内联受保护 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 命令。由于执行版再次修改，下一步必须第五轮 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第五轮 review：fresh spec compliance reviewer（Newton）PASS，但 fresh quality/feasibility reviewer（Poincare）FAIL，Newton PASS 因后续文档修订失效，不能计入最终 PASS gate。Poincare 的 P1 已验证有效：最终验证命令带 `surefire.failIfNoSpecifiedTests=false`，但缺新增 Market 测试类存在性断言，可能漏建或拼错仍空跑通过。P3 同步处理：Protected diff 改为失败型 `git diff --quiet -- ...`；V19 必须字段补 `creator/updater`，沿用 `TenantBaseDO/BaseDO` 审计列约定。执行版已修订：最终验证 Market focused tests 前增加六个新增测试文件 `test -f` 断言，覆盖 `MarketEventPublishOutboxServiceTest`、`MarketEventPublishWorkerTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishDependencyTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishEndToEndTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT`；Protected diff 改为 `git diff --quiet --`。由于执行版再次修改，下一步必须第六轮 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第五轮后加固：为彻底关闭新增测试空跑风险，最终验证新增 Surefire XML 计数断言，要求 `MarketEventPublishOutboxServiceTest`、`MarketEventPublishWorkerTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishDependencyTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishEndToEndTest`、`P1rMarketEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 均生成 XML，且 `tests>0`、failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；最终验证也内联 `/tmp/p1r7d-coverage-scan.*` 隔离 coverage scanner 命令。由于执行版再次修改，下一步仍必须第六轮 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现、提交或推进 completed。

P1R-7d 执行版第六轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Laplace spec compliance PASS、McClintock quality/feasibility PASS，均无 blocker。Laplace 已验证当前执行版覆盖 P1R-7d scope、recall 单 notification、payload allowlist、`MARKET_EVENTS_PAYLOAD_INVALID` fail-closed、worker 状态机、V19 审计列、dependency tree、Surefire XML 计数、隔离 coverage scanner 和 protected diff gate；McClintock 已验证 Market governance action 同事务 outbox、EventsPublishApi/SSE 可见链路、DTO String resourceId 与 payload numeric resourceRef、V19/worker/idempotency/anti-fake-green gate 可落地。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入 fresh implementer，不代表 P1R-7d 实现完成，也不代表 Events/P1R-7/Market completed。下一步允许派发 fresh implementer 按执行版实现；实现后必须重新进行 fresh spec review + fresh quality/feasibility review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或推进 completed。

P1R-7d implementation evidence 当前状态：Market source owner propagation 主体实现、V19 SQL、focused tests、P1R mixed executable gates、V19 Flyway `_test`、dependency tree gate、full reactor build、隔离 coverage scanner 与 protected diff gate 已落地，修复后 fresh implementation review 已双 PASS，但仍只收口到 `needs_verification`，不能推进 Events/P1R-7/Market completed。新增实现包括 Market server 直接依赖 `muse-module-events-api`、`MuseMarketEventPublishOutboxDO/Mapper`、`MarketEventPublishOutboxService/Impl`、`MarketEventPayloads` exact allowlist 与安全 message allowlist、`MarketEventPublishWorker`、`MuseMarketEventsProperties/Configuration` 默认 `muse.market.events.publish-worker.enabled=false`、配置化 `max-attempt` 与 `claim-timeout-seconds`、`V19__extend_market_events_publish_outbox.sql`，以及 `AdminMarketGovernanceServiceImpl.applyGovernanceAction` 在治理动作落库后同事务创建 Market Events publish outbox。Pasteur fresh spec review FAIL 的有效问题已修复：V19/DO/Mapper 补齐 `source_command_id`、`actor_user_id`、`preview_id`、`request_hash`，并将 `commandId/outboxId` 幂等 key 改为 `tenantId|actionId|ownerUserId|governance_action`；Kant fresh quality review FAIL 的有效问题已修复：Flyway IT `baseInsertSql()` 补齐四个 NOT NULL 字段，payload validator 收紧为 safe message allowlist；Tesla fresh spec review FAIL 的有效问题已修复：outbox `maxAttempt` 与 worker `claimTimeoutSeconds` 使用配置合同，payload timestamp 使用 governance action `createTime`，缺失时才回退当前时间。Volta quality/data-integrity review 曾 PASS，但 PASS 发生在 Tesla 修复前，已因后续代码和测试变化失效。验证 evidence：full reactor `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true` 为 62/62 modules success，Finished at `2026-06-07T20:36:27+08:00`；Market focused tests `AdminMarketGovernanceServiceTest,MarketEventPublishOutboxServiceTest,MarketEventPublishWorkerTest` 为 28/28 pass，surefire XML 为 11/6/11；一次旧类名 P1R mixed 命令只实际运行 29 tests，已丢弃不计入最终证据；修正后 P1R mixed executable gates 为 56/56 pass，包含 Market 3/2/4、Knowledge、AI 与 Events 既有 gate；`P1rMarketEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 为 4/4 pass，输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=19`、`target_schema_version=19`、`v19_table=muse_market_event_publish_outbox`，并验证 V19 表、索引、约束、trigger、四个补齐 required columns 与非法 insert 拒绝；dependency tree gate 证明 Market server 有 `muse-module-events-api` 且无 `muse-module-events-server`，Events server 无 AI/Knowledge/Market/Member/Content server；coverage scanner 仅在 `/tmp/p1r7d-final-coverage-scan.nhBVhM` 隔离副本运行 exit 0，summary 保持 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0，Events `streamEvents=dedicated/needs_verification`，Market 32 个 operation 均为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；真实 worktree 受保护 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 为空，`git diff --check` exit 0。修复后 fresh spec/correctness review（Pascal）PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 blocker；修复后 fresh quality/data-integrity/testing review（Mill）PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。残余非阻塞风险：claim SQL 未在领取阶段过滤 `attempt_count < max_attempt` 但 worker 会 claim 后转 dead_letter；E2E 仍是 focused harness；可后续把 required fields pre-insert 校验前移到 service、收窄 `insertIgnore` conflict target、统一 emittedAt 与 payload timestamp。memory 已更新：`docs/memorys/2026-06-07-P1R7dMarketSourceOwnerPropagation真实链路.md`。下一步可按逻辑分组准备提交，但提交、push 或任何 completed 推进仍需用户明确批准；提交前继续确认 protected diff、`git diff --check` 和 `git status --short --branch`。

P1R-7d 已按逻辑拆分提交并 push 到 `origin/dev/1.0.0`：`b36b153 feat(p1r): 接入 Market 事件传播真实链路`、`e8ed7d7 test(p1r): 收口 Market 事件传播真实链路门禁`。当前分支已与远端对齐到 `e8ed7d7`，worktree 后续仅新增 P1R-7 completed approval 预检审阅文档。P1R-7 completed approval 预检审阅版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-07-P1R7CompletedApproval预检审阅版.md`。该文档结论为可以启动 completed approval 预检，但不推荐直接把 Events/P1R-7 写成 `completed`；当前 AI/Knowledge/Market 三条 source owner propagation 只构成 `needs_verification` evidence。fresh spec/scope review（Confucius）PASS，fresh quality/feasibility review（Carver）PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。两位 reviewer 均确认本 PASS 只代表预检文档可进入下一步，不代表 coverage 状态可推进。关键待确认项：P1R-7 completed approval 是否只审批 Events `streamEvents`；Account(Member) 与 Content 是否仍是硬前置 source owner；若走 Events-only approval，是否允许执行版明确 Account/Content 作为后续 owner 而不阻塞本次 Events operation completed approval。未获明确批准前，后续默认不能直接写 Events-only completed 执行版并推进 coverage。

P1R-7e Account Source Owner Propagation 已按用户选择 1 启动审阅版，只做 Account/Member source owner evidence 路径，不进入 Events/P1R-7/Account completed。只读事实：Account owner 位于 `muse-module-member`；Member server 当前没有 `muse-module-events-api` 依赖；Events 合同已声明 `notification/quota_alert`；`AccountQuotaServiceImpl.adminCreateQuotaAdjustment` 成功后真实写入 `muse_member_entitlement_audit_log(change_type=quota_adjustment)`，具备 accountUserId、commandId 派生 idempotencyKey、quota snapshot 和 auditEventId；`MemberSecurityEventDO` 虽有读侧和 ack，但高敏导出写安全事件路径当前被 `normalizeRequest` fail-closed 阻断，不作为第一切片事实源。审阅版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-07-P1R7eAccountSourceOwnerPropagation审阅版.md`，推荐第一切片只覆盖 Account quota adjustment -> Account outbox -> worker -> EventsPublishApi -> `muse_unified_event` -> SSE owner-visible 的 `quota_alert` 链路；禁止发布 requestHash、reason 原文、operatorUserId、before/after snapshot、correlationId、外部调用详情或错误堆栈；不得修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report，不得推进 completed。下一步必须 fresh spec compliance review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 后才允许写执行版。

P1R-7e 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Gibbs spec compliance PASS，Ampere quality/feasibility PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。旧 Goodall feasibility review 对早期 security event 候选 FAIL，已验证有效并用于排除 security event；不计入最终审阅版 PASS gate。执行版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-07-P1R7eAccountSourceOwnerPropagation执行版.md`，锁定每条 `muse_member_entitlement_audit_log(change_type=quota_adjustment)` 一条 `notification/quota_alert`，`resourceRef.resourceId` 使用数值型 audit log id，`sourceRevision=__none__`，新增 `muse_account_event_publish_outbox`，Member server 只允许依赖 events-api，worker 默认 disabled，V20 migration，focused/mixed/Flyway `_test`/dependency tree/隔离 coverage scanner/protected diff gate。当前没有实现代码改动，没有 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report 改动，不得推进 Events/P1R-7/Account completed。下一步必须 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能派发实现或提交。

P1R-7e 执行版首轮 review：Pascal quality/feasibility PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 blocker；Schrodinger spec compliance FAIL，两个 P1 已验证有效：执行版写了不改 `docs/api-contracts/*/openapi.yaml` 但 protected 清单和 diff 命令漏掉 `docs/api-contracts/account/openapi.yaml`；Flyway `_test` 命令未继承 P1R-7d 已验证口径，缺 source `~/.config/muse-repo/infra.env`、缺清空 Java SOCKS/HTTP/HTTPS 代理，并使用了错误的 `MUSE_POSTGRES_USER` 变量。执行版已修订：protected 清单、Task 0 protected diff、最终 protected diff 均补 `docs/api-contracts/account/openapi.yaml`；Flyway `_test` 命令改为 source infra.env、使用 `MUSE_POSTGRES_USERNAME`、清空 Java proxy 参数并保留 surefire failIfNoSpecifiedTests=false。由于执行版已在 review 后修改，Pascal PASS 失效不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R-7e 执行版第二轮 review：Feynman spec compliance PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 blocker；Kant quality/feasibility FAIL，两个 P1 与两个 P2 已验证有效。P1：protected diff gate 只查 unstaged，漏查 staged protected 修改；P1R mixed gates 漏跑既有 `P1rAccountRealApiGateTest` 与 `P1rAccountRouteOwnershipTest`。P2：`sourceCommandId` 允许从 `idempotencyKey` 解析但未冻结冒号规则；payload timestamp fallback 在合同和 focused tests 中不一致。执行版已修订：Task 0 与最终 protected gate 同时执行 `git diff --quiet` 和 `git diff --cached --quiet`；P1R mixed gates 补 `P1rAccountRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAccountRouteOwnershipTest`，并新增覆盖 Account/Market/Knowledge/AI/Events/coverage 目标 XML 的显式 Surefire 计数脚本；`sourceCommandId` 固定为优先传原始 `reqVO.getCommandId()`，只有历史回查才用 `lastIndexOf(':')`；timestamp fallback 统一为 outbox `createTime`；Task 0 migration 检查按 Feynman 非阻塞建议改为 `sort -V`。由于执行版再次修改，Feynman PASS 失效不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R-7e 执行版第三轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Pauli execution spec compliance PASS，Hooke execution quality/feasibility PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。Pauli 已验证 scope 未扩大、protected staged/unstaged diff gate、V20 migration 编号前提、P1R mixed gate、Surefire XML 计数、隔离 coverage scanner 和 completed 边界；Hooke 已验证 Account quota adjustment 同事务 audit log / outbox 接入点、Events `notification/quota_alert` 合同、payload/resourceRef/sourceRevision/timestamp 合同和最终验证假绿口。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入 fresh implementer，不代表 P1R-7e 实现完成，也不代表 Events/P1R-7/Account completed。下一步允许派发 fresh implementer 按执行版实现；实现后必须重新进行 fresh spec review + fresh quality/feasibility review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或推进 completed。

P1R-7e controller final gate evidence 当前状态：Account/Member source owner propagation 主体实现、V20 SQL、Member focused tests、P1R mixed executable gates、V20 Flyway `_test`、dependency tree gate、full reactor build、隔离 coverage scanner 与 protected diff gate 已落地，证据只推进到 `needs_verification`，不得推进 Events/P1R-7/Account completed。新增实现包括 Member server 直接依赖 `muse-module-events-api`、`AccountEventPublishOutboxDO/Mapper`、`AccountEventPublishOutboxService/Impl`、`AccountEventPayloads` exact allowlist、`AccountEventPublishWorker`、`MuseAccountEventsProperties/Configuration` 默认 `muse.account.events.publish-worker.enabled=false`、配置化 `max-attempt` 与 `claim-timeout-seconds`、`V20__extend_account_events_publish_outbox.sql`，以及 `AccountQuotaServiceImpl.adminCreateQuotaAdjustment` 在每条 `muse_member_entitlement_audit_log(change_type=quota_adjustment)` insert 后同事务创建 Account Events publish outbox。关键合同已落地：每条 entitlement audit log 一条 outbox；`sourceOwner=account`、`sourceType=account_quota_adjustment`、`sourceId=auditLogId`、`sourceRevision=__none__`；`sourceCommandId` 优先使用原始 `reqVO.getCommandId()`，历史 fallback 使用 `lastIndexOf(':')`；Events payload 顶层只允许 `type/message/resourceRef/timestamp`，resourceRef 只允许 `resourceType/resourceId`，`resourceRef.resourceId` 保持 Number；payload 不包含 requestHash、reason、operatorUserId、before/after snapshot、correlationId、external detail、error stack、credential；payload timestamp 优先 audit log `createTime`，缺失时回退 outbox `createTime`；worker 终态回写使用 `publish_status='running' AND attempt_count=#{claimedAttemptCount}`，终态更新 0 行记录 stale claim 诊断日志。验证 evidence：full reactor `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true` exit 0，日志保留在 `/tmp/p1r7e-full-reactor-20260608022955.log`，机器统计 62 个 reactor `SUCCESS` 且包含 `BUILD SUCCESS`；clean build 后已重新运行 Member focused tests `AccountQuotaServiceTest,AccountEventPublishOutboxServiceTest,AccountEventPublishWorkerTest` 为 36/36 pass，Surefire XML tests 分别为 17/8/11 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；P1R mixed executable gates 为 73/73 pass，包含 Account 迁移/依赖/E2E/RealApi/RouteOwnership、Market、Knowledge、AI 与 Events 既有 gates；clean build 后 focused+mixed 目标 XML 合计 109 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；`P1rAccountEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用 `muse_p1r7e_account_events_publish_test` 真实 `_test` 库为 4/4 pass，migrations_executed=20，target_schema_version=20，验证 V20 表、3 个索引、11 个约束、trigger 与非法 insert 拒绝；clean build 后该 Flyway IT 已重新运行并保留 surefire XML，`TEST-cn.iocoder.muse.server.framework.api.P1rAccountEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT.xml` 机器校验为 tests=4、failures=0、errors=0、skipped=0；dependency tree gate 证明 Member server 有 `muse-module-events-api` 且无 `muse-module-events-server`，Events server 无 AI/Knowledge/Market/Member/Content server；coverage scanner 仅在 `/tmp/p1r7e-coverage-scan.Ozo9Xm` 隔离副本运行 exit 0，summary 保持 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0，Events `streamEvents=dedicated/needs_verification`，Account 33 operations 均为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；真实 worktree 受保护 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report diff 为空，`git diff --check` exit 0。当前未提交、未 push；下一步必须 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或推进 completed。

P1R-7e 最终 fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Banach correctness/spec review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；Raman quality/data-integrity/testing review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。两位 reviewer 均复核正确 worktree、protected diff、`git diff --check`、full reactor 可复核日志、focused/P1R/Flyway XML、隔离 coverage scanner 与 completed 边界。该双 PASS 只代表 P1R-7e Account quota adjustment source owner propagation evidence 可进入提交整理，不代表 Events/P1R-7/Account completed，严禁据此推进 completed。下一步可按逻辑分组提交；push 仍需单独确认或按用户后续指令执行。

P1R-7e 已按逻辑拆分提交并 push 到 `origin/dev/1.0.0`：`0f49802 docs(p1r): 记录 completed approval 预检边界`、`0e10caf feat(p1r): 接入 Account 事件传播真实链路`、`68cee5d test(p1r): 收口 Account 事件传播真实链路门禁`。当前分支已与远端对齐到 `68cee5d`。下一主线进入 P1R-7f Content Source Owner Propagation 审阅版；目标只做 Content `saveBlock` 成功后的 `muse_content_block_source_attribution(source_status=active)` -> Content publish outbox -> EventsPublishApi -> `muse_unified_event` -> SSE owner-visible 的审阅，不实现代码、不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage、不推进 completed。只读盘点事实：Content server 当前无 `muse-module-events-api` 依赖；最新 migration 为 V20，若 live 文件列表不变则 P1R-7f migration 应为 V21；`ContentAppServiceImpl.saveBlock` 在同事务内完成 command 预占、owner guard、revision 校验、Block 更新、source attribution 插入和 command audit；`muse_content_block_source_attribution` 有独立 id，且 `(tenant_id, block_id, revision)` 唯一；Events 当前声明 `notification/source_status_change`，但没有 `block_saved` subtype，`chunk` 是 AI 文本片段语义不能用于 Content save。审阅版已新增 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-08-P1R7fContentSourceOwnerPropagation审阅版.md`，推荐第一切片复用 `notification/source_status_change` 承载 Content block source attribution active 摘要，禁止发布正文、sourceSnapshot 原文、authorizationSnapshotId、lineage、license restriction、auditReason、requestHash 或 resultSnapshot。下一步必须 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 后才允许写执行版。

P1R-7f 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Harvey spec/scope review PASS、Chandrasekhar quality/feasibility review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2 blocker。Harvey 已验证 scope 严格停留在 Content `saveBlock -> block source attribution -> Events notification` 第一切片，不推进 completed、不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage、不覆盖全部 Content 写命令；Chandrasekhar 已验证 `saveBlock -> muse_content_block_source_attribution(source_status=active) -> Content outbox -> EventsPublishApi -> muse_unified_event -> SSE` 方案可落地，并要求执行版加入 P3 gate：Content worker/outbox 只能发布 `eventType=notification`、`notificationType=source_status_change`，必须有测试或静态 gate 防止误用 `chunk`。Halley quality reviewer 超时未返回，已丢弃不计入 review。下一步可以编写 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-08-P1R7fContentSourceOwnerPropagation执行版.md`；执行版完成后必须 fresh execution spec review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review，双 PASS 前不能实现代码、提交、push 或推进 Events/P1R-7/Content completed。

P1R-7f 执行版首轮 quality/feasibility review（Hypatia）FAIL，两个 P1 已验证有效：第一，`source_status=active` 合同没有被 V21 schema / worker gate 兜住，且 `deleteBlock` 真实会写 `sourceStatus=deleted`，非 active 边界实际可达；第二，E2E gate 允许 bare fake `EventsPublishApi` 返回 accepted，不能证明真实 `EventsPublishServiceImpl -> muse_unified_event -> visible query` 链路。旧 spec reviewer（Arendt）在首轮文档修订前长时间未返回，关闭动作被用户中断，视为 stale / discarded，不计入 gate。执行版已修订：V21 check 约束、SQL gate、Flyway `_test`、worker fail-closed 与 focused tests 均补 `source_status='active'`；E2E 成功路径收紧为必须使用真实 `EventsPublishServiceImpl`，只允许 in-memory / mocked `UnifiedEventMapper`，禁止 bare fake `EventsPublishApi` 作为成功证据。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec compliance review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不能实现代码、提交、push 或推进 Events/P1R-7/Content completed。

P1R-7f 执行版第二轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Huygens execution spec compliance PASS、Raman execution quality/feasibility PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Huygens 已验证当前执行版 scope、非目标、protected 边界、completed 边界、依赖边界、Chandrasekhar P3、Hypatia P1 修订、V21 / worker / E2E / Flyway / P1R mixed / `/tmp` scanner / protected diff gate 均已闭合；Raman 已验证 `saveBlock` 事务接入点、command replay 早退、`BlockSourceAttributionDO` 字段、Events `notification/source_status_change` 合同、`chunk` 不适配 Content save、V21 `source_status=active` 约束、payload exact allowlist、focused tests、真实 `EventsPublishServiceImpl` E2E 与防假绿门禁均可落地。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入 fresh implementer，不代表 P1R-7f 实现完成，也不代表 Events/P1R-7/Content completed。下一步允许派发 fresh implementer 按执行版实现；实现后必须重新进行 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或推进 completed。

P1R-7f controller final gate evidence 当前状态：Content source owner propagation 主体实现、V21 SQL、Content focused tests、P1R mixed executable gates、V21 Flyway `_test`、dependency tree gate、full reactor build、隔离 coverage scanner 与 protected diff gate 已落地，证据只推进到 `needs_verification`，不得推进 Events/P1R-7/Content completed。新增实现包括 Content server 直接依赖 `muse-module-events-api`、`ContentEventPublishOutboxDO/Mapper`、`ContentEventPublishOutboxService/Impl`、`ContentEventPayloads` exact allowlist、`ContentEventPublishWorker`、`MuseContentEventsProperties/Configuration` 默认 `muse.content.events.publish-worker.enabled=false`、配置化 `max-attempt` 与 `claim-timeout-seconds`、`V21__extend_content_events_publish_outbox.sql`，以及 `ContentAppServiceImpl.saveBlock` 在首次成功写入 `muse_content_block_source_attribution(source_status=active)` 后同事务创建 Content Events publish outbox。关键合同已落地：第一切片只覆盖 `saveBlock` 首次成功；`sourceOwner=content`、`sourceType=content_block_source_attribution`、`sourceId=blockId`、`sourceRevision=blockRevision`；`eventType=notification`、`notificationType=source_status_change`；幂等 key 基于 `tenantId|blockId|blockRevision|source_status_change`，outbox unique 覆盖 `(tenant_id, block_id, block_revision, notification_type)`；payload 顶层只允许 `type/message/resourceRef/timestamp`，resourceRef 只允许 `resourceType/resourceId`，message 固定为 `内容来源状态已更新`；payload 不包含正文、sourceSnapshot 原文、sourceObjectId、authorizationSnapshotId、lineagePayload、licenseRestrictionSnapshot、auditReason、requestHash、resultSnapshot 或错误堆栈；worker 只发布 active source status，非 active / invalid owner / invalid payload 均 fail-closed。验证 evidence：full reactor `mvn -o clean install -DskipTests -Dspring-boot.repackage.skip=true` exit 0，62/62 reactor modules success；clean build 后已重新运行 Content focused tests `ContentAppServiceTest,ContentEventPublishOutboxServiceTest,ContentEventPublishWorkerTest` 为 29/29 pass，Surefire XML tests 分别为 13/6/10 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；P1R mixed executable gates 为 88/88 pass，包含 Content 迁移/依赖/E2E/RealApi、Account、Market、Knowledge、AI 与 Events 既有 gates；focused+mixed 目标 XML 合计 117 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；`P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用 `muse_p1r7f_content_events_publish_test` 真实 `_test` 库为 4/4 pass，migrations_executed=21，target_schema_version=21，验证 V21 表、3 个索引、13 个约束、trigger 与 `event_type='chunk'`、`source_status='deleted'` 等非法 insert 拒绝；dependency tree gate 证明 Content server 有 `muse-module-events-api` 且无 `muse-module-events-server`，Events server 无 AI/Knowledge/Market/Member/Content server；coverage scanner 仅在 `/tmp/p1r7f-coverage-scan.N1DHvZ` 隔离副本运行 exit 0，summary 保持 completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0；真实 worktree 受保护 OpenAPI/scanner/coverage report staged 与 unstaged diff 均为空，`git diff --check` exit 0。当前未提交、未 push；下一步必须 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或推进 completed。

P1R-7f 最终 fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Hubble correctness/spec review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；Dalton quality/data-integrity/testing review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Hubble 复核了正确 worktree、protected diff、scope、`saveBlock` 接入点、outbox/worker source tuple、V21 防 `chunk/deleted`、真实 `EventsPublishServiceImpl` E2E、依赖边界与 `git diff --check`。Dalton 复核了 V21 migration 的 NOT NULL / unique / check / index / trigger、无 FK/敏感列、事务 outbox、幂等复用、payload exact allowlist、worker 状态机、focused/P1R/Flyway 测试质量与 Surefire XML 防空跑，读取目标 XML 得到 121 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0。该双 PASS 只代表 P1R-7f Content `saveBlock` source owner propagation evidence 可进入提交整理，不代表 Events/P1R-7/Content completed，严禁据此推进 completed。下一步可按逻辑分组准备提交；提交或 push 仍需用户明确批准。

P1R-7 completed approval 已启动新一轮审阅版刷新：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-P1R7CompletedApproval审阅版.md`。当前只做审批范围与证据口径冻结，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或业务代码，不推进 completed。已验证正确 worktree 为 `/Users/qingse/.config/superpowers/worktrees/oh-my-muse/dev-1.0.0`，写入审阅版前 `dev/1.0.0...origin/dev/1.0.0` 与远端对齐且 `git pull --ff-only origin dev/1.0.0` 为最新，HEAD 为 `f84c18f test(p1r): 收口 Content 事件传播真实链路门禁`；写入后当前仅有 `.agent` 与新审阅版文档变更待 review。隔离 scanner 只在一次性 `/tmp/p1r7-completed-approval-scan.JqNuWY` 运行 exit 0，summary 为 total=233、completed=100、needsVerification=133、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0；Events 唯一 operation 为 `streamEvents GET /app-api/muse/events = dedicated/needs_verification`。审阅版推荐后续执行版采用 operation-level approval，仅审批 `events:streamEvents`，不要把整个 `events` domain 加入 domain-level completed 白名单，避免未来 Events 新 operation 误继承 completed。下一步必须 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、修改 scanner/coverage report、提交、push 或推进 Events/P1R-7/任何 domain completed。

P1R-7 completed approval 审阅版 review gate：Curie fresh quality/feasibility review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；Lorentz fresh final spec/scope review PASS，无 P0/P1 blocker。Gibbs 对旧版 PASS 后提出的非阻塞反馈已修订到审阅版；Descartes 超时关闭、Godel 返回空结果，均不计入 gate。该双 PASS 只代表 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-P1R7CompletedApproval审阅版.md` 可进入执行版准备，不代表用户已批准 completed 状态推进，也不允许直接修改 scanner/coverage report。执行版启动前仍需用户明确确认三项：本轮只审批 `events:streamEvents`、采用 operation-level approval 而不是 events domain-level 白名单、执行版双 PASS 后再单独批准真实 coverage report 状态推进。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-09-P1R7CompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版锁定唯一审批对象为 `events:streamEvents / GET /app-api/muse/events`，推荐 operation-level approval：保留 AI/Knowledge domain-level completed，新增 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS={"events:streamEvents"}`，禁止把整个 `events` domain 加入白名单。目标状态仅允许 coverage 从 total=233/completed=100/needsVerification=133/incomplete=0/genericPersistence=0/ssePlaceholder=0 推进到 233/101/132/0/0/0；Market 32、Account 33、Content 51、Meta 16 必须仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。执行版当前只允许进入 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得实现、不得修改 scanner/test/report、不得提交/push，也不得宣称 P1R-7 completed。执行版双 PASS 后仍需用户明确批准三项，才允许真实 worktree 修改 scanner、`P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 和 coverage report。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版首轮 spec/scope review（Halley）FAIL，P1 已验证有效：执行版虽然写了禁止修改任何 OpenAPI，但实际 protected 清单和 Task 0 / Task 7 diff 命令漏掉 `docs/api-contracts/content/openapi.yaml` 与 `docs/api-contracts/meta/openapi.yaml`；当前仓库 `docs/api-contracts/*/openapi.yaml` 共有 account、ai、content、events、knowledge、market、meta 7 个合同。执行版已修订为显式覆盖 7 个 OpenAPI。Halley FAIL 不计入 PASS gate；由于执行版已在 review 后修改，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review。Quality reviewer James 若基于修订前文档返回 PASS，也不能单独构成双 PASS，需视是否覆盖修订内容决定是否重审。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版首轮 quality/feasibility review（James）FAIL，两个 P1 已验证有效并修订：第一，执行版要求新增 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest.should_only_promote_events_stream_events_for_p1r7_completed_approval`，但 Task 6 XML 计数仍按旧 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest=5` 与 total=106，会允许新增测试漏跑假绿；已改为 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest=6` 与 total=107。第二，最终 Task 7 只查 OpenAPI，没有校验最终 diff 只能包含本阶段允许文件；已新增 allowed-diff gate，允许路径限定为 scanner、`P1rApiCoverageReportTest`、coverage report、`.agent`、本阶段审阅/执行文档与 completed approval memory，任何额外路径必须停止。James FAIL 不计入 PASS gate；执行版已在 review 后修改，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版第二轮 spec/scope review（Lovelace）PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；但第二轮 quality/feasibility review（Feynman）FAIL，一个 P1 已验证有效：allowed-diff gate 只合并 `git diff --name-only` 与 `git diff --cached --name-only`，漏掉未跟踪文件，非目标业务实现/配置/测试可作为 untracked 混入且 gate 假绿。执行版已修订：allowed-diff gate 增加 `git ls-files --others --exclude-standard`，并要求最终 `git status --short --untracked-files=all` 只能显示 allowed 路径；完成条件同步纳入 allowed-diff gate 和 full status。由于执行版再次修改，Lovelace PASS 失效不能计入最终双 PASS，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版 allowed-diff gate dry-run 发现 Git 默认 `core.quotePath=true` 会把中文未跟踪文档转义成带引号八进制路径，导致 allowed-diff gate 对本阶段中文审阅/执行文档假失败。执行版已继续修订：allowed-diff gate 内部使用 `git -c core.quotePath=false ...` 包裹 `diff` / `diff --cached` / `ls-files --others --exclude-standard`；本地 dry-run 输出 `.agent`、审阅版、执行版三条 allowed 路径，并返回 `allowed_diff_gate=PASS`。由于执行版又发生非评审后修订，后续 fresh review 必须基于最新文件。

P1R-7 completed approval 执行版最终 fresh review 已双 PASS：Mencius spec/scope review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；Galileo quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Mencius 已验证唯一审批对象为 `events:streamEvents / GET /app-api/muse/events`、operation-level approval、不把整个 `events` domain 加入白名单、7 个 OpenAPI 保护面、allowed-diff 覆盖 unstaged/staged/untracked 且使用 `core.quotePath=false`、当前 coverage 仍为 `233/100/133/0/0/0`。Galileo 已验证 Python scanner 与 Java `P1rApiCoverageReportTest` approval 模型一致、`P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 计数提升到 6 且总 XML minimum 为 107、真实 scanner/report 修改必须在用户批准后、不会误推进 Market/Account/Content/Meta 或未来 Events operation。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可以进入用户批准点，不代表 P1R-7 completed 已完成；真实 worktree 修改 scanner、coverage gate test、coverage report 前仍必须由用户明确批准三项：只审批 `events:streamEvents`、采用 operation-level approval、允许 summary 从 `100/133` 推进到 `101/132`。

P1R-7 completed approval 实现中发现执行版 allowed-diff 范围缺口：真实 P1R mixed gate 还包含 `P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` 对旧 coverage 口径的硬断言，例如 `completedOperations=100`、`streamEvents=needs_verification`、剩余 1 个 SSE placeholder；在用户已批准 `events:streamEvents` operation-level completed 后，这些旧断言会使 Task 6 必然失败。2026-06-10 用户明确回复“允许”，已批准把上述 4 个 RealApi gate 纳入本阶段允许修改范围；修改边界仅限测试口径同步到 `completedOperations=101`、`needsVerificationOperations=132`、`events:streamEvents=dedicated/completed`、`ssePlaceholderOperations=0`，并继续断言 Market/Account/Content/Meta 不被连带推进。执行版 allowed-diff 已同步扩展；仍不得修改 OpenAPI、业务实现或把整个 `events` domain 加入 completed 白名单。

P1R-7 completed approval implementation evidence 当前状态：scanner 已落地 operation-level approval，保留 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}` 并新增 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS={"events:streamEvents"}`；`approved_completed_operation` 仍要求 completed 必须是 dedicated，且只允许 approved domain 或 approved operation key。coverage report 已在真实 worktree 由 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 生成，summary 从 `233/100/133/0/0/0` 推进为 `233/101/132/0/0/0`；domain 状态为 Account 33、Content 51、Market 32、Meta 16 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`，AI 41 与 Knowledge 59 继续 `dedicated/completed`，Events 1 为 `dedicated/completed`；唯一新增 completed 是 `events:streamEvents`。TDD 证据：`P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 新增单项 approval 测试先 RED（6 tests，1 failure，expected 101 but was 100），scanner/report 更新后 GREEN（6/6 pass）。旧 RealApi gate 同步后局部 gate 32/32 pass；完整 P1R focused gates 118/118 pass，failures/errors/skipped 均为 0；XML 防空跑计数 `p1r_completed_approval_gate_tests=118`。最终 `git diff --check` 通过，7 个 OpenAPI staged/unstaged diff 为空，allowed-diff gate PASS。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-09-P1R7CompletedApproval状态推进.md`。下一步必须派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称总 P1R completed。

P1R-7 completed approval fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Linnaeus spec/correctness review PASS，Hypatia quality/data-integrity/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Linnaeus 已验证 scanner 只新增 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS={"events:streamEvents"}`、未把 `events` domain 加入 completed domain、coverage 状态字段唯一变化为 `events:streamEvents dedicated/needs_verification -> dedicated/completed`、Account/Content/Market/Meta 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`、4 个旧 RealApi gate 只同步 approved coverage 口径、OpenAPI 与业务实现无 diff、`git diff --check` 通过。Hypatia 已验证 `/tmp` scanner、真实 report summary `233/101/132/0/0/0`、scanner validation 的非 dedicated / 非 approved domain / 非 approved operation 负向路径、P1R focused XML 118 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped=0、allowed-diff 仅包含本阶段 12 个允许路径、report 重生成噪声可解释。该双 PASS 只代表 `events:streamEvents` operation-level completed approval implementation 已具备收口条件；不代表总 P1R、Market、Account、Content、Meta completed。提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R-7 completed approval 已提交并 push 到 `origin/dev/1.0.0`：`85c5422 test(p1r): 收口 P1R-7 completed approval 门禁`。当前 coverage 事实为 total=233、completed=101、needsVerification=132、incomplete=0、genericPersistence=0、ssePlaceholder=0；AI 41、Knowledge 59、Events `streamEvents` 1 为 `dedicated/completed`，Account 33、Content 51、Market 32、Meta 16 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。下一阶段已启动总审阅版 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-10-P1RRemainingDomainCompletedApproval审阅版.md`，目标是冻结剩余业务域 completed approval 的总路线，推荐顺序为 Meta -> Account -> Market -> Content；本阶段目前只写总审阅版，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或业务代码，不推进任何剩余 domain completed。下一步必须对该总审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 后才可进入第一个 domain（推荐 Meta）completed approval 审阅版。

P1R Remaining Domain Completed Approval 总审阅版已完成 fresh 双 review：Turing spec/scope review PASS、Euclid quality/feasibility review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker；首轮 Epicurus 对 anti-fake-green 基线的 P1 已修订并由第二轮确认关闭。当前已按用户确认进入 Meta completed approval 审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-10-P1RMetaCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。该审阅版只冻结 Meta 16 个 `dedicated/needs_verification` operation 的 completed approval 候选范围、证据缺口、推荐 domain-level approval 与 operation-level fallback，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 Meta 业务代码，也不推进 Meta/Account/Market/Content completed。只读盘点事实：Meta 已有 `AdminMetaSchemaController`、`AdminProtectionNodeController`、`AdminFunctionChainController`、dedicated services、command/audit、V10 SQL、`P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 和 `P1rMetaMigrationSqlTest`；当前最大缺口是 V10 真实 Flyway `_test`、审批后 coverage gate 口径、外部 owner impact preview completed 口径和 XML 防空跑证据。下一步必须对 Meta 审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或修改 scanner/report/gate。

P1R Meta operation-level completed approval implementation 当前状态：本轮没有做 Meta domain-level approval，只把 11 个 MetaSchema 管理 operation 加入 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS`，并把 coverage summary 从 `233/101/132/0/0/0` 推进为 `233/112/121/0/0/0`。Meta 当前为 `dedicated/completed:11`、`dedicated/needs_verification:5`；仍保留 needs_verification 的 5 个 operation 是 `listProtectionNodes`、`getProtectionNode`、`listFunctionChains`、`previewFunctionChainImpact`、`activateFunctionChainVersion`。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest` / `P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 失败，GREEN 后 focused gates `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rMetaRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest,P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` 为 36/36 pass。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-10-P1RMeta状态推进.md`。该状态不代表 Meta 16/16 completed，不代表 Account/Market/Content completed，也不代表总 P1R completed。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation completed approval 已启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-10-P1RMetaRemaining5CompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只覆盖 `listProtectionNodes`、`getProtectionNode`、`listFunctionChains`、`previewFunctionChainImpact`、`activateFunctionChainVersion`，推荐继续 operation-level approval，不把 `meta` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist。只读盘点事实：当前 coverage summary 为 `233/112/121/0/0/0`，Meta 为 `dedicated/completed:11` 与 `dedicated/needs_verification:5`；ProtectionNode 已有 dedicated Controller/Service、版本头、权限、active 过滤、missing node 错误和结构化字段读模型；FunctionChain 已有 dedicated Controller/Service、command replay、requestHash、published-only activation、expected active version、validation/impact preview 同源校验、protection boundary 阻断、audit 和 active version 切换；V10 只有静态 SQL gate，仍缺真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 证明 FunctionChain / ProtectionNode 表、partial unique、trigger 和非法 insert 拒绝。当前未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或业务代码，下一步必须 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、修改 scanner/report/gate、提交、push 或推进剩余 5 个 operation completed。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Hegel scope review PASS、Feynman feasibility review PASS，均无阻塞项。Hegel 已验证范围严格限定为 `listProtectionNodes`、`getProtectionNode`、`listFunctionChains`、`previewFunctionChainImpact`、`activateFunctionChainVersion`，明确排除 MetaSchema 11、Account、Market、Content、总 P1R 和 `meta` domain-level allowlist，并保留用户批准点、Flyway `_test`、XML 防空跑、protected diff、allowed-diff；非阻塞建议是不要混用 branch up-to-date 与 working tree clean。Feynman 已验证 operation-level approval 符合当前 scanner / Java gate 模型，FunctionChain / ProtectionNode 证据要求与现有代码路径对得上，真实 Flyway `_test` 和假绿防护要求合理；非阻塞建议是把批准前禁止改 scanner/report 与批准后 allowed diff 阶段化写清。当前已新增执行版 `docs/agent-specs/2026-06-10-P1RMetaRemaining5CompletedApproval执行版.md`，只写执行方案，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、业务代码或测试代码。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进剩余 5 个 operation completed。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation 执行版首轮 review：Anscombe execution spec/scope PASS，无阻塞项；Copernicus execution quality/feasibility FAIL，P1 有效：执行版 P1R mixed gate 命令要求运行 `P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest`、`P1rContentRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAccountRealApiGateTest`，但 XML 防空跑 required 清单只检查 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 与 `P1rMetaRealApiGateTest`，会让非目标 domain gate 假绿。执行版已修订，把上述 6 个 P1R gate 类全部加入 XML 防空跑 required 清单并要求 `tests>=1`、failures/errors/skipped 均为 0。由于执行版已在 review 后修改，Anscombe PASS 失效，下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation 执行版第二轮 review：Parfit execution spec/scope FAIL，P1 有效：批准后 allowed diff 预置允许修改部分非目标 domain gate，把非目标 gate 从“运行和 XML 防空跑”扩大成可修改 scope。Pauli feasibility review 因超时关闭，不计入 gate。执行版已修订：非目标 domain gate 文件只允许运行和读取 XML，不在本轮 allowed diff 内；若 implementation 发现必须修改任一非目标 domain gate，必须停下说明原因并取得用户明确批准。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation 执行版第三轮 review：Laplace execution spec/scope PASS，无阻塞项；Kant execution quality/feasibility FAIL，P1 有效：当前 `P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` 仍硬编码 `completedOperations=112` 或 Meta `11 completed / 5 needs_verification`，但执行版又要求 scanner/report 推进到 `117/116` 后运行这些 mixed gates；若不允许同步这些 legacy gate 文件，执行路径自相矛盾。执行版已修订为两段式批准：默认不改非目标 gate；但真正实现前必须把上述 4 个 legacy mixed gate 的 summary / Meta 状态断言同步列为用户明确批准项，且修改范围仅限 `117/116` 与 Meta `16/0`，继续断言 Account / Market / Content 不被推进。未批准该项时不得启动实现。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation 执行版第四轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Mendel execution spec/scope PASS、Nietzsche execution quality/feasibility PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 阻塞项。Mendel 已验证执行版只审批剩余 5 个 Meta operation，不把 `meta` 加入 domain-level allowlist，不混入 MetaSchema 11、Account、Market、Content 或总 P1R；legacy mixed gate 同步是单独用户批准项，默认 allowed diff 未无条件扩大。Nietzsche 已验证 Kant P1 已关闭，4 个 legacy gate 文件列表与代码硬编码一致，Account/Content 未纳入可改范围，XML 防空跑覆盖 focused + mixed gates，scanner/report/coverage 口径统一为 `233/117/116/0/0/0`，`previewFunctionChainImpact` 的 `externalRuntime=pending` 仍受约束。当前仍未实现、未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、业务代码或测试代码。下一步进入用户批准点：必须明确批准 1) 只审批剩余 5 个 Meta operation；2) 继续 operation-level approval，不把 `meta` 加入 domain allowlist；3) 允许按执行版修改 scanner、coverage report、P1R gate tests、新增 Flyway `_test` 和 memory；4) 允许同步 4 个 legacy P1R mixed gate 文件 `P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` 的 summary / Meta 状态断言。未获四项批准前不得启动实现。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation completed approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准四项执行前置条件，本轮只把 `meta:listProtectionNodes`、`meta:getProtectionNode`、`meta:listFunctionChains`、`meta:previewFunctionChainImpact`、`meta:activateFunctionChainVersion` 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `meta` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI 或 Meta 业务实现。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只在 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS` 追加上述 5 个 Meta operation。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 失败，失败点为 expected completed=117 but was 112、Meta expected 16 completed but was 11；GREEN 后 scanner 输出 summary `233/117/116/0/0/0`，Meta 16 个 operation 全为 `dedicated/completed`，Account 33、Market 32、Content 51 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。新增 `P1rMetaFlywayMigrationIT` 使用真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r2_meta_remaining5_test` 验证 V1-V10 Flyway，输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=10`、`successful_migration_count=10`、`target_schema_version=10`、`flyway_latest=10:extend meta real api schema`，并验证 FunctionChain / ProtectionNode 表、索引、约束、trigger、JSONB/默认值、duplicate unique 与 NOT NULL 拒绝路径。验证 evidence：`python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过；P1R mixed gates `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rMetaRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest,P1rMarketRealApiGateTest,P1rContentRealApiGateTest,P1rAccountRealApiGateTest` 为 45/45 pass；Meta focused XML 计数为 ProtectionNodeServiceTest 3、FunctionChainServiceTest 12、AdminProtectionNodeControllerTest 7、AdminFunctionChainControllerTest 7、FunctionChainGuardTest 4、MetaProtectionNodeGuardTest 5、P1rMetaMigrationSqlTest 3、P1rMetaFlywayMigrationIT 4，全部 failures/errors/skipped=0；P1R XML 防空跑覆盖 16 个目标测试类，全部通过；`git diff --check` 通过，`docs/api-contracts` staged/unstaged protected diff 为空。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-10-P1RMetaRemaining5状态推进.md`。当前尚未提交、未 push；下一步必须 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称总 P1R/Account/Market/Content completed。

P1R Meta 剩余 5 个 operation completed approval fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Dewey spec/correctness review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings；Carver quality/data-integrity/testing review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings。Dewey 已验证当前目录正确、scanner 未加入 `meta` domain allowlist、只新增 ProtectionNode 2 个和 FunctionChain 3 个 operation-level completed、coverage summary 为 `233/117/116`、Account/Market/Content 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`、4 个 legacy mixed gate 仅同步 summary/Meta 口径且保留非目标 domain 断言、OpenAPI 与 Meta 业务实现无 diff、memory/.agent 未过度声明。Carver 已验证 `P1rMetaFlywayMigrationIT` 的 `_test` 库名硬闸、credential query 拒绝、密码环境变量读取、URL/user 脱敏、`target=10`、V10 DDL 对象/partial unique/JSONB/默认值/NOT NULL/非法 insert 拒绝、Surefire XML 反假绿、Account/Content mixed gate 覆盖、allowed-diff 与 protected diff。该双 PASS 只代表本轮 Meta remaining 5 operation-level completed approval implementation 具备收口条件；不代表总 P1R、Account、Market 或 Content completed。提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Account Completed Approval 已按用户确认启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-11-P1RAccountCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只冻结 Account 33 个 `dedicated/needs_verification` operation 的 completed approval 证据标准和推荐路线，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 Account 业务实现，也不推进 Account/Market/Content/总 P1R completed。只读盘点事实：当前 coverage summary 为 `233/117/116/0/0/0`，Account 33 个 operation 全部仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；Account owner 位于 `muse-module-member` Account 子域，已有 dedicated Controller/Service/DTO/DAL/Guard、V11 Account schema、V20 Account events outbox、`P1rAccountRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAccountRouteOwnershipTest` 和 P1R-7e quota adjustment -> Account outbox -> Events SSE needs-verification evidence。审阅版推荐不要做 Account domain-level 33/33 completed approval，而是先做 operation-level 或证据切片；New-API runtime、FileService/download、call attribution external source、Market purchase/license/publish projection、安全事件生产路径仍是 completed 缺口。下一步必须对该 Account 审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或修改 scanner/report/gate。

P1R Account Completed Approval 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Franklin spec/scope review PASS、Gauss quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 阻塞项。Franklin 已验证审阅版只覆盖 Account completed approval 审阅阶段，不进入执行版/实现，不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/report/业务状态；没有把 P1R-7e quota alert evidence 扩写成 Account 整域 completed；完整保留单独用户批准、operation-level approval、protected diff、allowed diff、XML 防空跑、真实 `_test` 和历史证据不得当 fresh evidence 的口径。Gauss 已验证当前 scanner 模型支持 Account operation-level 路线，New-API runtime、FileService/download、call attribution external source、Market projection、security event source fact 等缺口完整，后续执行版测试要求覆盖 Account focused tests、P1R mixed gates、fresh XML、真实 PostgreSQL `_test`、protected diff、allowed diff 和 rollback。该双 PASS 只代表审阅版可进入执行版编写；不代表 Account completed，也不允许修改 scanner/report/gate。

P1R Account Completed Approval 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-11-P1RAccountCompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版推荐第一轮只做 operation-level approval，不把 `account` 加入 domain-level allowlist；第一批精确锁定 10 个 Account operation：`getCurrentUser`、`getProfile`、`updateProfile`、`adminListAccountUsers`、`adminGetUserEntitlements`、`getAppEntitlements`、`adminGetBalanceSnapshots`、`getAppBalanceSnapshots`、`adminCreateQuotaAdjustment`、`adminListQuotaAdjustments`。目标 summary 仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/127/106/0/0/0`，Account 目标为 `completed=10`、`needsVerification=23`；`getAppUsage` 与 `adminListUsageRecords` 因 integration call / attribution source 上游事实仍未纳入第一轮。当前只写执行方案和 `.agent`，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、业务实现或 gate test。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Account completed。

P1R Account Completed Approval 执行版 fresh review 已双 PASS：James execution spec/scope review PASS、Huygens execution quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无阻塞项。James 已按执行版修订后最新版复审，确认第一轮严格限定 10 个 Account operation、不做 Account 33/33 domain-level completed、未获 4 项批准前不得实施、只追加 operation-level allowlist、23 个 Account operation 继续 needs_verification，且 allowed diff 已补入同阶段既有审阅版文档避免自相矛盾。Huygens 已验证 scanner/gate 模型支持 operation-level approval、TDD RED/GREEN 顺序可执行、XML 防空跑最低计数与当前测试类一致、Flyway `_test` gate 可证明 V1-V20 clean migrate 并可按需扩展 V11 assertion、4 个 legacy mixed gate 同步已作为单独用户批准项处理、protected diff / allowed diff / rollback 可操作。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入用户批准点；不代表 Account completed，也不允许在未获批准前修改 scanner/report/gate 或推进 coverage。

P1R Account 第一批 operation-level completed approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 10 个 Account operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `account` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Account 业务实现或数据库迁移。10 个 completed operation 为 `getCurrentUser`、`getProfile`、`updateProfile`、`adminListAccountUsers`、`adminGetUserEntitlements`、`getAppEntitlements`、`adminGetBalanceSnapshots`、`getAppBalanceSnapshots`、`adminCreateQuotaAdjustment`、`adminListQuotaAdjustments`；`getAppUsage`、`adminListUsageRecords` 和 New-API / FileService / attribution / Market projection / security event 相关 23 个 Account operation 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只在 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_OPERATIONS` 追加上述 10 个 `account:*` key。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rAccountRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest,P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` 为 37 tests / 10 failures，失败点为 expected completed=127 but was 117、Account expected 10 completed but was 0；GREEN 后 scanner 输出 summary `233/127/106/0/0/0`，Account 为 `completed=10`、`needs_verification=23`。验证 evidence：`python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过；Account focused verification 为 Member 114/114 pass 与 muse-server 19/19 pass；P1R mixed gates `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rAccountRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest,P1rMarketRealApiGateTest,P1rContentRealApiGateTest,P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 为 46/46 pass；`P1rAccountEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_account_completed_approval_test` 为 4/4 pass，输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=20`、`successful_migration_count=20`、`target_schema_version=20`、`flyway_latest=20:extend account events publish outbox`；增强证据 `AccountEventPublishOutboxServiceTest,AccountEventPublishWorkerTest` 为 19/19 pass；XML 防空跑覆盖 25 个目标 XML，合计 192 tests，failures/errors/skipped 均为 0。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-11-P1RAccount状态推进.md`。当前尚未提交、未 push；下一步必须 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Account 33/33、Market、Content 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Account 第一批 operation-level completed approval fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Nash spec/correctness review PASS、Copernicus quality/data-integrity/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Nash 已验证正确 worktree、scanner 未加入 `account` domain allowlist、只追加批准的 10 个 `account:*` operation key、report 为 `233/127/106/0/0/0` 且 Account `10 completed / 23 needs_verification`、usage/New-API/FileService/attribution/Market projection/security event 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`、Account/Coverage gate 绑定具体 key、非目标 Market/Content/Meta/AI/Knowledge/Events 口径正确、OpenAPI 与业务实现无 diff、memory/.agent 未过度宣称。Copernicus 已验证 XML 防空跑 25 个目标 XML 合计 192 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0，XML 时间集中在本轮验证窗口，Flyway IT 只连接 `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_account_completed_approval_test` 且 URL/user 脱敏、密码来自环境变量、clean/migrate V1-V20 target V20 并验证 V20 outbox 表/索引/约束/trigger，allowed diff 只落在 scanner/report/P1R gates/spec/memory 文档。该双 PASS 只代表本轮 Account 第一批 10 个 operation-level completed approval 具备收口条件；不代表 Account 33/33、Market、Content 或总 P1R completed。提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Market Completed Approval 已启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-11-P1RMarketCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只冻结 Market 32 个 `dedicated/needs_verification` operation 的 completed approval 证据标准和推荐路线，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 Market 业务实现，也不推进 Market/Content/Account remaining/总 P1R completed。只读盘点事实：当前 coverage summary 为 `233/127/106/0/0/0`，Market 32 个 operation 全部仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；Account 当前为 `completed=10`、`needs_verification=23`。并行子代理只读复核结论：第一候选是 Marketplace 浏览/收藏 6 个 operation，但 `favoriteAsset` / `unfavoriteAsset` 存在实现要求 `X-Command-Id` 而 OpenAPI/report `requiresCommandId=false` 的合同不一致；如不批准 OpenAPI 合同修正，第一批应降级为纯读候选。purchase/install/handoff/governanceImpact 缺目标 owner 消费闭环与 Account 读侧 E2E；publish/review/governance 可作为后续强候选但缺 fresh completed 级验证；appeal 申诉审计、治理 outbox、Account projection 不应混成 completed 闭环。下一步必须对该 Market 审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或修改 scanner/report/gate。

P1R Market Completed Approval 审阅版首轮 review：Popper spec/scope review PASS，无阻塞项；Ptolemy quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，P1 有效：后续执行版原要求只点名 `P1rMarketRealApiGateTest` / `P1rApiCoverageReportTest` 与泛化 mixed gates，不足以覆盖 `P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest` 等 legacy gate 中硬编码的 `completed=127`、`needsVerification=106` 或 Market 全 `needs_verification` 断言。审阅版已修订：执行版必须枚举所有读取全局 summary 或 Market 状态的 P1R mixed gate，至少包括 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest`、`P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`；需要同步断言的文件必须列入单独用户批准项、allowed diff 和 required XML 防空跑清单；目标值公式化为 `completed=127+N`、`needsVerification=106-N`、Market `completed=N / needs_verification=32-N`，其中 `N` 只能来自用户批准的 Market operation。由于审阅版已在 review 后修订，Popper PASS 失效，下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review。

P1R Market Completed Approval 审阅版第二轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Godel spec/scope review PASS、Jason quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 阻塞项。Godel 已验证文档仍停留在审阅版边界，未推进 Market 32/32、Market domain、Account remaining、Content 或总 P1R completed；浏览/收藏 6 个 operation 只作为候选；`favoriteAsset` / `unfavoriteAsset` 的 `X-Command-Id` 合同缺口仍是执行前硬门槛；legacy mixed gate 修订覆盖首轮 P1。Jason 已验证 OpenAPI 当前确实缺 favorite/unfavorite `X-Command-Id` header，而 controller/service 会强制校验；scanner 支持识别 required `X-Command-Id` header，后续修 OpenAPI 是可落地路径；`listMarketplaceRecommendations` 确实为 fallback 排序，已要求用户确认；handoff/install/events outbox/Account projection 等暂不推荐切片的缺口与代码事实一致。非阻塞建议：执行版需列明 Account remaining 23 / Content 防误推进的具体 gate 类名，写清第一批 `N` 的分支目标值，补 missing/blank `X-Command-Id` HTTP 失败断言，并把 recommendations fallback 写成明确的用户可批准业务口径。该双 PASS 只代表 Market 审阅版可进入执行版编写；不代表 Market completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 OpenAPI、scanner、report、gate 或业务实现。

P1R Market Completed Approval 执行版初稿记录：该初稿曾把 Marketplace 浏览/推荐/收藏候选合并进第一批，但已在首轮 execution quality/feasibility review 后判定证据不足并被下一段修订记录取代。当前有效执行版必须以后续 4-operation 修订版本为准；初稿不能作为实现、审批、提交或推进 Market completed 的依据。

P1R Market Completed Approval 执行版首轮 review：Meitner execution spec/scope review PASS，Mill execution quality/feasibility review FAIL。Mill 的 5 个 P1 已只读验证为有效：`listMarketplaceRecommendations` 仍存在 OpenAPI 个性化推荐语义与 fallback 排序实现不闭合；MockMvc + mock service/mapper + Flyway 组合不足以证明 favorite/unfavorite HTTP 到真实 DB 闭环；V8 favorite 表、唯一约束、command 约束和 trigger 在 `P1rMarketFlywayMigrationIT` 中不是 mandatory evidence；XML 防空跑只读旧 surefire XML 存在假绿风险；`listMarketplaceAssets` 缺 pageNo/pageSize 1..100 边界证据且 `PAGE_SIZE_NONE=-1` 可能触发全量查询。执行版已修订：第一批从 6 个 operation 收紧为 4 个 `getMarketplaceAsset`、`listMarketplaceCategories`、`favoriteAsset`、`unfavoriteAsset`；目标 summary 改为 `233/131/102/0/0/0`，Market 改为 `completed=4`、`needsVerification=28`；`listMarketplaceAssets` 与 `listMarketplaceRecommendations` 明确保留 `dedicated/needs_verification`；新增 mandatory `P1rMarketDiscoveryFavoriteCompletedApprovalIT` HTTP + 真实 PostgreSQL `_test` gate，沿用 `p1r.flyway.url/user` system property 与 `P1R_FLYWAY_PASSWORD` 环境变量，禁止通过 JVM property 传密码；Flyway favorite schema/约束/trigger assertion 改为 mandatory 且 XML 最低 tests 提到 4；GREEN 阶段 Maven test 验证命令要求删除目标 XML、记录 exported `RUN_START_EPOCH` 并校验 XML mtime/tests/failures/errors/skipped，TDD RED 只要求确认失败发生在本次运行窗口且失败点来自旧 report mismatch。由于执行版已在 review 后修订，Meitner PASS 不能计入最终 gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。未双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Market completed。

P1R Market Completed Approval 修订执行版 fresh review 当前状态：Parfit execution spec/scope review PASS，无阻塞项；Harvey execution quality/feasibility review FAIL，反馈已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 只读验证并修订。有效修订包括：Market HTTP+DB `_test` 建库命令改为 `PGPASSWORD=... psql -h/-p/-U/-d`，不再把密码嵌入 URI 或 JVM system property；`P1rMarketDiscoveryFavoriteCompletedApprovalIT` 最低 XML tests 从 6 提到 8，mandatory 覆盖 `DELETE /favorite` 缺 `X-Command-Id`、missing/invisible asset 对 favorite/unfavorite 不写 command/favorite fact；rollback 策略按“撤回 OpenAPI commandId header”和“保留 OpenAPI commandId 合同”两条分支分别恢复 `requiresCommandId=false/true`。由于执行版再次修订，Parfit PASS 不能计入最终 gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review。未双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Market completed。

P1R Market Completed Approval 修订执行版最终 fresh review 已双 PASS：Banach execution spec/scope review PASS、Avicenna execution quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Banach 已验证第一批严格限定 4 个 operation：`getMarketplaceAsset`、`listMarketplaceCategories`、`favoriteAsset`、`unfavoriteAsset`；不做 Market domain-level allowlist；目标值仅为获批后目标 `233/131/102/0/0/0` 与 Market `4 completed / 28 needs_verification`；`listMarketplaceAssets` 与 `listMarketplaceRecommendations` 继续 `needs_verification`；OpenAPI `X-Command-Id` 修正是单独用户批准项；allowed/prohibited diff 与非目标域边界自洽。Avicenna 已验证 Harvey 三项 blocker 已关闭：建库命令使用 `PGPASSWORD` 且 Maven 不通过 URI/JVM property 暴露密码，HTTP+DB `_test` 最低 8 tests 覆盖 detail/categories/favorite/unfavorite happy/error/replay/inactive，Flyway favorite assertion、XML 防空跑、rollback 双分支和目标 summary/Market 4/28 均已落到执行步骤。当前仍未实现、未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Market 业务实现或 gate test；下一步进入用户批准点。未获得用户明确批准四项前，不得实施本执行版、提交、push 或推进 Market completed。

P1R Market 第一批 operation-level completed approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 4 个 Market operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `market` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 Market 业务实现或数据库迁移。4 个 completed operation 为 `getMarketplaceAsset`、`listMarketplaceCategories`、`favoriteAsset`、`unfavoriteAsset`；`listMarketplaceAssets`、`listMarketplaceRecommendations` 以及 purchase/install/handoff/governance/publish/review/appeal/projection 相关 28 个 Market operation 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`。OpenAPI 仅在 `docs/api-contracts/market/openapi.yaml` 为 `favoriteAsset` / `unfavoriteAsset` 增加 required `X-Command-Id` header，修正已有实现强校验与合同不一致；scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加上述 4 个 `market:*` operation key。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 focused P1R gates 因 expected completed=131 but was 127、Market expected 4 completed but was 0 等断言失败；GREEN 后 scanner 输出 summary `233/131/102/0/0/0`，Market 为 `completed=4`、`needs_verification=28`。验证 evidence：`python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过；Market focused verification 为 Market module 26/26 pass 与 muse-server 25/25 pass；新增 `P1rMarketDiscoveryFavoriteCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口与真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_market_discovery_favorite_completed_approval_test` 为 9/9 pass，覆盖 detail/categories/favorite/unfavorite happy/error/replay/inactive/no-write；增强 `P1rMarketFlywayMigrationIT` 使用真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_market_completed_approval_test` 为 4/4 pass，输出 V1-V15 clean migrate 并验证 favorite 表、索引、约束、trigger、duplicate tenant/user/asset 拒绝、duplicate tenant/command_id 拒绝和 inactive update trigger 可执行；P1R mixed gates `P1rApiCoverageReportTest,P1rMarketRealApiGateTest,P1rEventsRealApiGateTest,P1rAiRealApiGateTest,P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest` 为 33/33 pass；XML 防空跑覆盖 13 个目标 XML，全部 failures/errors/skipped=0；`git diff --check` 通过；OpenAPI diff 仅限 Market favorite/unfavorite `X-Command-Id` header。fresh correctness review 指出新增 Discovery IT 脱敏 `p1r.flyway.url/user` 后未恢复会污染同 JVM 后续 Flyway IT；该问题已修复为 Discovery IT 与 Flyway IT 均保存原始 system property 并在 `@AfterAll` 恢复，组合验证使用真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_market_combined_completed_approval_test`，普通顺序与 `-Dsurefire.runOrder=reversealphabetical` 强制反向顺序均通过，均为 13/13 pass。fresh data/testing review 提到“真实 HTTP”若理解为 socket 级 live server则当前证据不足；按执行版原文，本轮要求是 WebApplicationContext/MockMvc + real mapper + `_test` DB，不是 live socket server，memory 已将措辞收窄为 MockMvc HTTP 入口证据；其提出的 status CHECK / FK 属于新增迁移范围，当前执行版明确禁止改迁移，作为后续 Market schema hardening 风险保留，不作为本轮 approved diff；Dirac 复审提出 raw Surefire XML 会记录原始 host/user 但未泄露 password，当前作为 P3 artifact 边界记录：raw XML 不应直接外发，外发前需清洗 host/user 或后续改造 URL/user 传递方式。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-11-P1RMarket状态推进.md`。当前尚未提交、未 push；下一步必须重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Market 32/32、Content、Account remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Market 第一批 operation-level completed approval fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Raman spec/correctness review PASS、Hubble data-integrity/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 阻塞项。Raman 已验证正确 worktree、scanner 未加入 `market` domain allowlist、只追加 4 个 `market:*` operation key、coverage summary 为 `233/131/102/0/0/0`、Market 为 `4 completed / 28 needs_verification`、`listMarketplaceAssets` 与 `listMarketplaceRecommendations` 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`、OpenAPI diff 仅限 favorite/unfavorite required `X-Command-Id`、Market main/java 与 SQL diff 为空、文档未宣称 Market 32/32 或总 P1R completed。Hubble 已验证 Discovery IT 使用 WebApplicationContext + MockMvc + real mapper/service + PostgreSQL `_test`，Flyway IT 覆盖 favorite unique/index/trigger/duplicate/no-write 证据，双向组合顺序 13/13 pass 关闭同 JVM system property 污染风险，13 个目标 XML 合计 85 tests 且 failures/errors/skipped 均为 0。非阻塞注意事项：favorite `status` CHECK 与 FK 属于后续 schema hardening；raw Surefire XML 暴露 DB host/user 但未泄露 password，外发前需清洗。该双 PASS 只代表本轮 Market 第一批 4 个 operation-level completed approval 具备收口条件；不代表 Market 32/32、Content、Account remaining 或总 P1R completed。当前尚未提交、未 push；提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Content Completed Approval 已按用户确认启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-11-P1RContentCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只冻结 Content 51 个 `dedicated/needs_verification` operation 的 completed approval 证据标准和推荐路线，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 Content 业务实现，也不推进 Content/Account remaining/Market remaining/总 P1R completed。只读盘点事实：当前 coverage summary 为 `233/131/102/0/0/0`，Content 51 个 operation 全部仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`；P1R-7f 已给 `saveBlock -> source attribution active -> Content outbox -> Events -> SSE owner visible` 提供 needs-verification evidence，但仍不等同 `saveBlock` completed。审阅版推荐不要做 Content 51/51 domain-level completed approval；第一批推荐只做 8 个 operation：`listWorks`、`getWork`、`listChapters`、`getChapter`、`listBlocks`、`getBlock`、`saveBlock`、`getBlockSourceAttribution`。只读子代理提出 15 个用户端 CRUD operation 也具备实现候选性，但当前 `createWork` / `updateWork` / `createChapter` 等写命令存在 OpenAPI 或 coverage `requiresCommandId` 口径与服务端 VO 不一致风险，因此审阅版默认不把创建/更新/删除合同修正夹带进第一批。导入/导出/解析/Meta projection/AI planning candidate/style/suggestion 均因 FileService、AI、Knowledge、Meta 等外部 owner closure 缺口暂缓；admin read 和正式 planning section 可作为后续独立切片。下一步必须对该 Content 审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或修改 scanner/report/gate。

P1R Content Completed Approval 审阅版首轮 review：Feynman spec/scope review PASS，但 Herschel quality/feasibility review FAIL；Feynman PASS 因后续文档修订失效，不能计入最终 PASS gate。Herschel 的 3 个 P1 和 1 个 P2 已只读验证并修订：第一，`saveBlock` completed approval 依赖 P1R-7f source/event 证据，执行版必须把 `P1rContentEventsPublishMigrationSqlTest`、`P1rContentEventsPublishDependencyTest`、`P1rContentEventsPublishEndToEndTest`、`P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 纳入必跑和 XML 防空跑；第二，HTTP/DB IT 必须覆盖 tenant 与 owner 双隔离，至少 seed 两个 tenant，验证同 owner 不同 tenant 不可见、跨 tenant `saveBlock` 不写 block/source/outbox、写入行 `tenant_id` 正确；第三，Content completed IT 与 Content events Flyway IT 必须保存并在 `@AfterAll` 恢复 `p1r.flyway.url/user`，做普通顺序与反序组合验证，raw Surefire XML 只能作为本地证据，外发前清洗 DB host/user；第四，执行版必须明确 Flyway current=V21、成功 SQL migration 数量 21、V21 outbox 表/索引/约束/trigger 与 invalid insert 拒绝，且 V9 planning schema 不属于本第一批业务验收范围。由于审阅版已在 review 后修订，下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Completed Approval 审阅版第二轮 review：Bernoulli spec/scope review PASS，但 Wegener quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL；Bernoulli PASS 因后续文档修订失效，不能计入最终 PASS gate。Wegener 的 2 个 P1 已只读验证并修订：第一，执行版必须把 `P1rAccountRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 纳入必跑、allowed diff 审批项和 XML 防空跑边界，防止 Content 状态推进时漏掉 Account remaining 23 与 Meta completed 防回退断言；第二，8 个候选 operation 的 runtime evidence 必须包含 shadow-path matrix，覆盖列表空页、资源不存在、path mismatch、跨 owner / 跨 tenant 拒绝，以及 `saveBlock` 缺 `commandId`、缺 `expectedRevision`、缺 `sourceSnapshot`、revision conflict 等 no-write 负路径。由于审阅版已在 review 后修订，下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Completed Approval 审阅版第三轮 review：Leibniz quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，P1 有效并已只读验证：`saveBlock` 与 `getBlockSourceAttribution` 都通过 `requireOwnedBlock(userId, workId, blockId)` 绑定 path workId 与 block.workId，因此执行版必须覆盖“同 owner 但 block 属于另一个 work”的 path mismatch；`saveBlock` 要断言 block/source/outbox/command no-write 或事务回滚后行数不变，`getBlockSourceAttribution` 要断言错误响应且不泄露 attribution。由于审阅版已在 review 后修订，本轮任何已返回或未返回的 PASS 都不能计入最终 PASS gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review。

P1R Content Completed Approval 审阅版第四轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Fermat spec/scope review PASS、Faraday quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Fermat 已验证审阅版仍停留在 review/scope 决策层，第一批 8 个 operation、`N=8` 目标值、非首批 scope 排除、`P1rAccountRealApiGateTest` / `P1rMetaRealApiGateTest` 非目标防回退、P1 修订点和 `.agent` 失效链路均自洽。Faraday 已验证后续执行版硬条件覆盖 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 PostgreSQL `_test`、真实 mapper/service、Flyway V1-V21、V21 outbox schema/trigger/invalid insert、fresh XML 防空跑、system property restore 与普通/反序组合验证；8 ops runtime matrix 已覆盖 happy/empty/missing/path mismatch/same-owner wrong workId/cross owner/cross tenant/写命令缺字段/revision conflict/no-write/outbox no-duplicate。该双 PASS 只代表 Content 审阅版可进入执行版编写；不代表 Content completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 scanner/report/OpenAPI/业务实现/gate tests。

P1R Content Completed Approval 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-12-P1RContentCompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版只锁定第一批 8 个 operation-level approval：`listWorks`、`getWork`、`listChapters`、`getChapter`、`listBlocks`、`getBlock`、`saveBlock`、`getBlockSourceAttribution`；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist。目标 summary 仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/139/94/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `completed=8`、`needsVerification=43`。执行版明确要求用户再次批准 4 项后才可实施：8 ops 清单、operation-level approval、allowed diff、6 个 mixed gate 的 summary / Content / 非目标域防回退断言同步。当前只写执行方案和 `.agent`，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Content 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Completed Approval 执行版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Rawls execution spec/scope review PASS、Planck execution quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Rawls 已验证正确 worktree、HEAD `0032774`、执行版严格锁定第一批 8 个 operation、不做 Content 51/51、不加入 `content` domain-level allowlist、目标值为获批后 `233/139/94` 与 Content `8 completed / 43 needs_verification`、43 个保留 `needs_verification` operation 与 coverage report 机械比对无缺失或额外项、allowed/prohibited diff 自洽且保护面无 diff。Planck 已验证 TDD RED/GREEN、Content HTTP+DB `_test` gate、`saveBlock` 依赖的 source/event/Flyway V21 mandatory gate、system property restore、普通/反序组合验证、XML 防空跑和 diff gate 均可执行；其只读审阅未运行 Maven/Flyway，后续 implementation 仍必须按执行版实际跑完验证。该双 PASS 只代表 Content 执行版可进入用户批准点；不代表 Content completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 scanner/report/OpenAPI/业务实现/SQL migration/gate tests。下一步必须由用户明确批准四项：1) 8 ops 清单；2) operation-level approval 且不加 `content` domain allowlist；3) 执行版 allowed diff；4) 6 个 mixed gate 的 summary / Content / 非目标域防回退断言同步。

P1R Content 第一批 operation-level completed approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 8 个 Content operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `content` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。8 个 completed operation 为 `listWorks`、`getWork`、`listChapters`、`getChapter`、`listBlocks`、`getBlock`、`saveBlock`、`getBlockSourceAttribution`；其余 43 个 Content operation 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加 8 个 `content:*` operation key；coverage summary 已推进为 `233/139/94/0/0/0`，Content 为 `8 completed / 43 needs_verification`。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 focused P1R gates 因目标 summary 与 Content 8 个 operation 尚未 completed 而失败；GREEN 后 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过并重生成 report。新增 `P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 mapper/service 与 PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_content_core_completed_approval_test`，当前目标为 12/12 pass，覆盖 8 个 operation 的 happy/empty/missing/path mismatch/same-owner wrong work/cross owner/cross tenant、`saveBlock` command/revision/source/outbox/command replay/conflict/no-write、`getBlockSourceAttribution` active/current/empty/no-write；fresh testing review（Hooke）指出 chapter/block missing 负路径缺显式 HTTP 断言，已补 `missing work chapter list`、`missing chapter detail`、`missing chapter block list`、`missing block detail` 和 no-write outbox 断言。修复后已重跑 Core IT：`P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` tests=12、failures=0、errors=0、skipped=0，XML mtime 在本次运行窗口内。增强 `P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 保存并恢复 `p1r.flyway.url/user`，V1-V21 clean migrate 4/4 pass，验证 V21 outbox 表、索引、约束、trigger、`attempt_count<0` 与 `max_attempt<=0` invalid insert 拒绝。Hooke 修复后已重跑组合验证：普通顺序与 `-Dsurefire.runOrder=reversealphabetical` 均通过，实际 Surefire 顺序两次均为 Flyway IT 先、Core IT 后，合计 16/16 pass，证明 Flyway 脱敏/恢复未污染后续 Core IT；该参数未改变实际顺序，留痕不得写成已证明 Core->Flyway 反向顺序。Content focused suite 已 fresh XML 防空跑；P1R mixed gates 已重跑并 XML 防空，49/49 pass。scanner `--check` 已重跑，summary 仍为 `233/139/94/0/0/0`，Content 仍为 `8 completed / 43 needs_verification`，代表性非目标 operation 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。protected OpenAPI diff 为空，`git diff --check` 通过。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-12-P1RContent状态推进.md`。当前还需要重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + quality/data-integrity/testing review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Content 第一批 implementation fresh review 第一轮结果：Bohr correctness review FAIL、Euclid testing/data-integrity review FAIL，同源 P1 有效：`P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` 未覆盖执行版 mandatory 的 `saveBlock` 缺 `expectedRevision` 与缺 `sourceSnapshot` 两个 HTTP+DB no-write 负路径。已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 验证反馈有效：执行版第 513 行明确要求这两项，`BlockSaveReqVO` 对两字段均有 required 语义。已最小修复：在 `should_rejectSaveBlockValidationRevisionConflictAndCommandConflictWithoutDirtyWrite` 中补 `p1r-content-missing-expected-revision` 与 `p1r-content-missing-source-snapshot` 两个请求，并复用 `assertSnapshotUnchanged` 断言 block/source/outbox/command 未写入。修复后已重跑 `P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` tests=12、failures=0、errors=0、skipped=0；已重跑 Core+Flyway 组合验证，tests=16、failures=0、errors=0、skipped=0，两个目标 XML 均为新产物。当前仍需重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + quality/data-integrity/testing review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Content 第一批 operation-level completed approval fresh implementation re-review 已双 PASS：Mendel correctness review PASS，无 findings、无 residual risks；Anscombe testing/data-integrity review PASS，无 findings、无 testing gaps。Mendel 已验证 Bohr/Euclid P1 已关闭，`P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` 覆盖缺 `expectedRevision` 与缺 `sourceSnapshot` 两个 `saveBlock` HTTP 负路径并复用 no-write 断言，coverage summary 为 `233/139/94/0/0/0`，Content 精确为 `8 completed / 43 needs_verification`，scanner 未加入 `content` domain allowlist，只追加 8 个 `content:*` operation key，OpenAPI、Content main/java 与 SQL migration diff 均为空，Core 12/12、Core+Flyway 16/16、P1R mixed gates 49/49 通过。Anscombe 已验证 testing/data-integrity 口径，无新增 blocker；唯一残余风险是 raw Surefire XML 仍可能包含本地 DB host/user，但未发现 password 泄露，外发前需清洗。该双 PASS 只代表 Content 第一批 8 个 operation-level completed approval 具备提交条件；不代表 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 已启动下一批审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-12-P1RContentPlanningCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只推荐 formal planning section 两个 operation-level completed approval：`content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem`；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Content 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。只读盘点事实：当前 HEAD 为 `3ced553 test(p1r): 收口 Content 第一批 completed approval 门禁`，coverage summary 为 `233/139/94/0/0/0`，Content 为 `8 completed / 43 needs_verification`；`SavePlanningItemRequest` OpenAPI required 为 `commandId/content/expectedRevision`，与 `SavePlanningItemReqVO` required 口径一致；V9 已有 `muse_content_planning_section`、unique `(tenant_id, work_id, section_key)`、work index 与 update trigger；`ContentPlanningServiceImpl` 对 `getPlanning` / `savePlanningItem` 只依赖 Content owner 自有 Work / PlanningSection / Command / Audit 事实。下一步必须对该审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、修改 scanner/report/gate、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 审阅版首轮 review：Lovelace spec/scope review PASS，无 findings；Kierkegaard quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，两个 P1 有效：第一，`savePlanningItem` 后续执行版 matrix 缺同 commandId 但不同 request hash / sectionKey / workId 的 `CONTENT_COMMAND_ID_CONFLICT` no-write 证明；第二，V9 planning schema mandatory gate 只列 table/unique/index/trigger，不足以证明 `tenant_id`、JSONB 类型、默认值、revision 和 `update_time` 行为。审阅版已修订：新增 command conflict no-write mandatory matrix；扩展 V9 schema gate 到列类型、nullable/default、tenant 隔离、JSONB 存储、revision/schema/projection 默认、duplicate unique 拒绝、CAS 后 revision+1 与 `update_time` 推进。由于审阅版已在 review 后修改，Lovelace PASS 失效；下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 审阅版第二轮 review：Hume spec/scope review PASS，无 findings；Aquinas quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，P1 有效：command conflict matrix 写成“至少覆盖不同 content、不同 sectionKey 或不同 workId”，会允许执行版只测其中一类而遗漏 path scope hash 证明。审阅版已修订为三个独立 mandatory HTTP+real DB 子用例：同 commandId 不同 content、同 commandId 不同 sectionKey、同 commandId 不同 workId，三者都必须返回 `CONTENT_COMMAND_ID_CONFLICT` 并断言 planning row count/content/revision、command count、audit/result snapshot 保持首次成功状态。由于审阅版已在 review 后再次修改，Hume PASS 失效；下一步必须重新派发 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 审阅版第三轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Darwin spec/scope review PASS、Erdos quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Darwin 已验证审阅版只推荐 `content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem` 两个 operation-level completed approval，41 个继续 `needs_verification` 的 Content operation 与 coverage 差集一致，目标值 `233/141/92` 与 Content `10/41` 可由当前 `233/139/94`、Content `8/43` 加 N=2 机械推导，未获批准前不得修改 scanner/report/gate、实现、提交或 push。Erdos 已验证 OpenAPI 与 VO required 口径一致且 `sourceSnapshot` optional；目标 operation 只依赖 Content 本域 Work / PlanningSection / Command / Audit，不依赖 AI candidate、style-check、Meta 或 FileService；V9 schema gate 已覆盖 tenant_id、JSONB、默认值、unique/index/trigger、CAS update_time；`savePlanningItem` matrix 已覆盖 create/update/replay、三类 command conflict no-write、validation、revision/schema/projection conflict、unique conflict、owner/tenant no-write；P1R mixed gates、XML 防空跑和 protected diff 要求齐备。该双 PASS 只代表审阅版可进入执行版编写；不代表 `getPlanning` / `savePlanningItem` completed，也不得直接修改 scanner/report/gate 或提交/push。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-12-P1RContentPlanningCompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版只锁定 `content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem` 两个 operation-level approval；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。目标 summary 仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/141/92/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `10 completed / 41 needs_verification`。执行版明确要求用户再次批准 4 项后才可实施：2 ops 清单、operation-level approval、allowed diff、mixed gate summary / Content / 非目标域防回退断言同步。当前只写执行方案和 `.agent`，未修改 scanner、coverage report、P1R gate、OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 执行版首轮 review：Kant execution spec/scope review PASS；Russell execution quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，两个 P1 有效并已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 只读验证后修订。第一，执行版 Task 4 的 HTTP+DB `_test` 上下文漏写 `MuseWebAutoConfiguration` 所需的 `ApiErrorLogCommonApi` stub 与真实 tenant SQL 拦截器要求，已修订为复用 `P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT` 的 Web/MyBatis/DataSource 模式，明确注册 `TenantLineInnerInterceptor + TenantDatabaseInterceptor(new TenantProperties())` 和 `ApiErrorLogCommonApi` test-local stub。第二，普通顺序 HTTP 请求无法稳定触发 `savePlanningItem` insert unique catch；已有 row 会先进入 existing 分支，因此不能把 existing-row revision conflict 冒充 duplicate unique conflict。执行版已修订为：DB unique 约束证据放入 V9 schema gate，由直接 JDBC insert 验证 duplicate `(tenant_id, work_id, section_key)` 被 PostgreSQL 拒绝；服务层 `DuplicateKeyException` 转 `CONTENT_REVISION_CONFLICT` 由 focused `ContentPlanningServiceTest` 覆盖；HTTP matrix 覆盖 existing-row revision/schema/projection conflict 与 no-write。由于执行版已在 review 后修改，Kant PASS 失效；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility/testing review，双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 执行版第二轮 fresh review 已双 PASS：Hypatia execution spec/scope review PASS、Ramanujan execution quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。Hypatia 已验证执行版严格锁定 `content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem` 两个 operation-level completed approval，不加入 `content` domain allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration；目标值 `233/141/92` 与 Content `10/41` 可由当前 `233/139/94`、Content `8/43` 加 N=2 机械推导，41 个保留 `needs_verification` operation 与审阅版一致，Russell P1 修订未扩大 scope。Ramanujan 已验证 Task 4 最小 Web/MyBatis/DataSource 测试上下文可落地，`ApiErrorLogCommonApi` stub、`TenantLineInnerInterceptor + TenantDatabaseInterceptor(new TenantProperties())`、facade stubs、tenant context、credential redaction、system property restore 与 XML 防空跑要求齐备；unique conflict 证据已改为 V9 schema gate 直接 JDBC duplicate 约束验证 + focused service `DuplicateKeyException -> CONTENT_REVISION_CONFLICT`，HTTP matrix 不再假装触发 insert unique catch。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入用户批准点；不代表 `getPlanning` / `savePlanningItem` completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 scanner、coverage report、P1R gate、OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration。下一步必须由用户明确批准四项：1) 2 ops 清单；2) operation-level approval 且不加 `content` domain allowlist；3) 执行版 allowed diff；4) mixed gate 的 summary / Content / 非目标域防回退断言同步。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 `content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem` 两个 operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `content` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加两个 `content:*` operation key；coverage summary 已推进为 `233/141/92/0/0/0`，Content 为 `10 completed / 41 needs_verification`，`savePlanningItem.requiresCommandId=true`。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 focused P1R gates 因目标 summary 仍为 139、`content/getPlanning` 仍为 `needs_verification` 而失败；GREEN 后 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过并重生成 report。新增 `P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 mapper/service 与 PostgreSQL `_test` 库，单类验证 `11/11 pass`，覆盖 V9 planning schema 的 JSONB/default/tenant/unique/index/trigger/duplicate/CAS update_time 证据、`getPlanning` happy/empty/missing/cross-owner/cross-tenant/no-write，以及 `savePlanningItem` create/update/replay、三类 command conflict（不同 content/sectionKey/workId）、validation、revision/schema/projection conflict、missing/cross-owner/cross-tenant no-write 与全租户 command/outbox 污染断言。Ohm fresh correctness/spec review FAIL，3 个 P1 有效：缺 `commandId`/缺 `content` validation 未做全租户 command/outbox no-write；command/audit snapshot 断言不足，未覆盖 tenant_id、request_hash、result_snapshot 与 audit requestSummary/operationId/status/reason 等关键事实；执行版 Task 3 mandatory focused `ContentPlanningServiceTest` 与 `AppContentPlanningControllerTest` 未运行、XML 缺失。已修复并验证：缺 `commandId`/缺 `content` 改为全租户 command/outbox no-write；command/audit snapshot 增加 `tenantId`、`requestHash` 长度、`result.newRevision/sectionKey`、audit `side/operationId/reason/status/resultSummary`、`requestSummary.operationId/sectionKey/expectedRevision/saveMode` 断言；Task 3 focused tests fresh 运行 `ContentPlanningServiceTest 15/15` 与 `AppContentPlanningControllerTest 7/7`，两个 XML mtime 均在运行窗口内。组合验证 `P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用独立 `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_content_planning_combined_test`，首次因只设置 `P1R_CONTENT_COMPLETED_PASSWORD` 而缺 `P1R_FLYWAY_PASSWORD` 失败，确认根因为既有 Flyway IT 环境变量要求；仅调整运行环境同时设置 `P1R_CONTENT_COMPLETED_PASSWORD` 与 `P1R_FLYWAY_PASSWORD` 后重跑通过，合计 `27/27 pass`。P1R mixed gates 已重跑并 XML 防空，`49/49 pass`；scanner `--check` 已重跑；protected OpenAPI diff 为空，`git diff --check` 通过。此前 fresh testing/data-integrity review Curie PASS 已被 Ohm 后续修复推进为过期证据，只保留为历史记录；Kepler 超时后关闭，无可用结论。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-13-P1RContentPlanning状态推进.md`。当前必须重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh quality/data-integrity/testing review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval implementation fresh re-review 进展：Locke correctness/spec review PASS，确认 scope/diff、scanner operation-level approval、coverage `233/141/92/0/0/0`、Content `10/41`、非目标 operation 仍 `needs_verification`、Planning IT 与 Ohm 3 个 P1 修复均符合执行版；Locke 残余风险为执行版 allowed diff memory 文件日期与实际 `2026-06-13` 不一致，已修订执行版 allowed diff。Hilbert testing/data-integrity review FAIL，2 个 P2 有效：V9 schema gate 未显式断言 `schema_version`、`projection_version`、`revision` 三列 `NOT NULL`；savePlanning missing/cross-owner/cross-tenant no-write 未逐一断言目标 planning row 未创建。已最小修复：补三列 `columnNullable(...)=NO` 断言；补 missing work、cross-owner、cross-tenant 当前 tenant 与目标 tenant planning row count 为 0 的断言。修复后已 fresh 重跑 `P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT`，tests=11、failures=0、errors=0、skipped=0，XML mtime 为 `2026-06-13 01:53:08 +0800`。当前需要重新派发 fresh correctness/spec re-review + testing/data-integrity re-review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval implementation fresh re-review 已双 PASS：Epicurus correctness/spec re-review PASS，确认 protected diff 为空、scope 未扩大、scanner 仍只追加 `content:getPlanning`/`content:savePlanningItem`、执行版 allowed diff 已改为实际 memory 路径、Hilbert 两个 P2 已关闭、coverage report 为 `233/141/92/0/0/0` 且 Content 为 `10 completed / 41 needs_verification`；Epicurus 未运行 Maven 测试，只做只读 diff/source/docs/report 复核。Nietzsche testing/data-integrity re-review PASS，确认 schema NOT NULL、missing/cross-owner/cross-tenant 目标 row no-write、缺 commandId/缺 content 全租户 command/outbox no-write、command/audit snapshot 解析断言、fresh XML `P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT 11/11`、`.agent`/memory 留痕和 `git diff --check` 均无新 blocker；Nietzsche 未运行 Maven 测试，只解析现有 XML 并运行只读 diff check。残余风险：Surefire XML 含本地 classpath、user.dir、测试 DB URL 等本机信息，外发前需清洗；新增 IT 与 memory 当前仍未提交，提交前必须确认纳入正确 commit。该双 PASS 只代表 `content:getPlanning` 与 `content:savePlanningItem` 两个 operation-level completed approval 具备收口条件，不代表 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed；提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval implementation final verification：fresh 双 PASS 后已重跑 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 并重新生成 report；Task 3 focused `ContentPlanningServiceTest,AppContentPlanningControllerTest` fresh 运行 `22/22 pass` 且 XML fresh；P1R mixed gates fresh 运行 `49/49 pass`；Content combined DB gate `P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` fresh 运行 `27/27 pass`；`git diff --check` 无输出；protected `docs/api-contracts`、Content main/java、SQL diff 为空；正确 jq 验证 summary 为 `233/141/92/0/0/0`，Content 为 `10 completed / 41 needs_verification`，`getPlanning` 与 `savePlanningItem` 为 `dedicated/completed`，`listPlanningCandidates`、`createStyleCheck`、`getStyleCheckResult` 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification`。当前状态具备提交候选条件，但仍未提交、未 push。

P1R Content Planning Completed Approval 已收口提交并 push：当前 HEAD 为 `2692af3 test(p1r): 收口 Content Planning completed approval 门禁`，`dev/1.0.0` 与 `origin/dev/1.0.0` 对齐，worktree 干净。当前 coverage summary 为 `233/141/92/0/0/0`，domain 状态为 Account `10 completed / 23 needs_verification`、Content `10 completed / 41 needs_verification`、Market `4 completed / 28 needs_verification`、Meta `16 completed / 0 needs_verification`。本段只是状态校正，不代表新增 operation completed。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval 已启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminReadCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只推荐下一批 operation-level approval 为 `content:adminListWorks`、`content:adminGetWork`、`content:adminListChapters` 三个 admin read operation；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Content 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。只读盘点事实：这 3 个 operation 当前为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=false`，`adminRiskAction` 当前为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=true`，应单独作为治理写命令切片。推荐目标值仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/144/89/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `13 completed / 38 needs_verification`。下一步必须对该审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、修改 scanner/report/gate、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Beauvoir spec/scope review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings，确认只覆盖 `content:adminListWorks`、`content:adminGetWork`、`content:adminListChapters`，未夹带 `adminRiskAction`、admin import/export task、Content 写命令、Content domain-level completed 或其它 domain，目标值 `233/144/89` 与 Content `13/38` 可机械推导，非目标 38 个 operation 与 coverage 差集一致。Einstein quality/testing review PASS，无 findings；残余执行版要求为 mixed gates 必须点名 `P1rApiCoverageReportTest`、`P1rContentRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAiRealApiGateTest`、`P1rKnowledgeRealApiGateTest`、`P1rEventsRealApiGateTest`、`P1rAccountRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMarketRealApiGateTest`、`P1rMetaRealApiGateTest`，且 RBAC 缺权限拒绝必须用真实 method security 上下文证明，不能只靠 `@PreAuthorize` 反射。该双 PASS 只代表审阅版可进入执行版编写；不代表 3 个 admin read operation completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 scanner/report/gate 或实现。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval 执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminReadCompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版只锁定 `content:adminListWorks`、`content:adminGetWork`、`content:adminListChapters` 三个 operation-level approval；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。目标 summary 仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/144/89/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `13 completed / 38 needs_verification`。执行版已把审阅版 residual 写成硬门槛：mixed gate 点名 8 个类，Admin Read IT 必须启用 method security 与 test-local `ss` bean，证明授权成功和缺权限拒绝；HTTP+real DB `_test` 必须覆盖 admin RBAC、tenant interceptor、API version、riskFlag 聚合、正文不泄露、missing/cross tenant 和 no-write。当前只写执行方案和 `.agent`，未修改 scanner、coverage report、P1R gate、OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/testing review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval 执行版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Sagan execution spec/scope review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings，确认执行版严格锁定 `content:adminListWorks`、`content:adminGetWork`、`content:adminListChapters`，未夹带 `adminRiskAction`、admin import/export task、Content 写命令、Content domain-level completed 或其它 domain；目标值 `233/144/89` 与 Content `13/38` 可由当前 `233/141/92`、Content `10/41` 加 3 个 operation 机械推导；allowed/forbidden diff 匹配，mixed gate 覆盖 8 个类。Cicero execution quality/testing review PASS，无 findings；P3 residual 为 implementation 需避免把“admin read 必需 mapper”误解成只注册 Work/Chapter/Block/GovernanceAction mapper，因为 `ContentAdminServiceImpl` 仍注入 ImportTaskMapper/ExportTaskMapper，执行版已补充要求所有 `@Resource` 依赖可启动。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入用户批准点；不代表 3 个 admin read operation completed，也不允许未获批准前修改 scanner/report/gate 或实现。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 `content:adminListWorks`、`content:adminGetWork`、`content:adminListChapters` 三个 operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `content` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加三个 `content:*` operation key；coverage summary 已推进为 `233/144/89/0/0/0`，Content 为 `13 completed / 38 needs_verification`。`content:adminRiskAction` 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=true`，admin import/export task、Content 写命令、AI planning candidate、style check、Meta projection、FileService 和 import/export/parse operation 仍保持 `needs_verification`。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 focused P1R gates 因目标 summary 仍为 141、admin read 3 个 operation 仍为 `needs_verification` 而失败；GREEN 后 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过并重生成 report。新增 `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 mapper/service、method security + test-local `ss` bean 与 PostgreSQL `_test` 库，单类验证 `5/5 pass`，覆盖安全配置拒绝、admin list/detail/chapter read、API version、缺权限 403、tenant interceptor、riskFlag 聚合、missing/cross tenant、正文不泄露和 no-write。Content focused `ContentAdminServiceTest,AdminContentControllerTest` fresh 运行 `21/21 pass`；Content combined DB gate `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用 `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_content_admin_read_combined_test` fresh 运行 `32/32 pass`；P1R mixed gates fresh 运行 `49/49 pass`；`git diff --check` 通过；protected OpenAPI diff、Content main/java diff、SQL migration diff 均为空。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminRead状态推进.md`。当前必须重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness review + fresh quality/data-integrity/testing review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval implementation fresh review 进展：Lorentz correctness review PASS，无 findings；Hegel testing/data-integrity review FAIL，2 个有效问题已修复。P1：`should_listWorksWithFiltersGovernanceTenantIsolationAndNoBodyLeak` 先执行两次 admin read 后再调用测试自身 `deleteGovernanceActions()`，最后只按治理行数 0 做 no-write，可能遮蔽 read 路径新增/删除治理事实。P2：旧 `assertNoAdminReadWrites` 只比较 work/chapter/block/governance/command/outbox 行数，不能发现 admin read 意外 UPDATE 既有字段、revision、status、reason 或 update_time。修复方式：在 `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT` 中新增 `ContentFactSnapshot`，用 `row_to_json(t)::text` 对 `muse_content_work`、`muse_content_chapter`、`muse_content_block`、`muse_content_governance_action`、`muse_content_command_log`、`muse_content_event_publish_outbox` 做请求前后全表快照比对；每个 admin read happy/error/RBAC/API version 请求都包进 `assertNoContentMutationDuring`；riskFlag 空结果在测试自身删除治理事实后重新采样快照，不把测试 DML 混入 no-write 窗口。修复后已 fresh 重跑 `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT`，`5/5 pass`；Content combined DB gate `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` fresh 重跑 `32/32 pass`。当前需要重新派发 fresh implementation correctness/spec re-review + testing/data-integrity re-review；双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称本轮收口。

P1R Content Admin Read Completed Approval implementation fresh re-review 已双 PASS：Peirce correctness/spec re-review PASS、Carver testing/data-integrity re-review PASS，均无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings。Peirce 已验证正确 worktree、OpenAPI/Content main/java/SQL migration protected diff 为空、scanner 仅追加 3 个 Content admin read operation、coverage 为 `233/144/89/0/0/0`、Content 为 `13 completed / 38 needs_verification`、`adminRiskAction` 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=true`、mixed gate 防回退断言同步、Hegel P1/P2 已通过全表快照 no-write 关闭，且 `.agent`/memory 没有宣称 Content 51/51 或总 P1R completed。Carver 已验证 `ContentFactSnapshot` 用 `row_to_json(t)::text` 覆盖 work/chapter/block/governance_action/command_log/event_publish_outbox 的 INSERT/DELETE/UPDATE，所有 admin read happy/error、API version deny、RBAC deny 请求都包进 `assertNoContentMutationDuring`，riskFlag 空结果在测试自身 DML 后重新建立 no-write baseline；修复后主证据 `P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT 5/5`、Content combined `32/32`、P1R mixed gates `49/49`、scanner `233/144/89` 均为 fresh 产物。Carver P3 residual 为 focused `ContentAdminServiceTest/AdminContentControllerTest` XML 早于 no-write 修复，但这两个源码本轮未改；该 residual 已通过重新运行 focused Content tests 关闭，fresh 结果为 `ContentAdminServiceTest 13/13`、`AdminContentControllerTest 8/8`，合计 `21/21 pass`。该双 PASS 只代表本轮 Content Admin Read 3 个 operation-level completed approval 具备收口候选条件；不代表 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。提交或 push 仍需用户明确指令。

P1R Content Admin RiskAction Completed Approval 已启动审阅版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminRiskActionCompletedApproval审阅版.md`。本审阅版只推荐下一批 operation-level approval 为 `content:adminRiskAction` 一个治理写命令；不把 `content` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Content 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。只读盘点事实：当前 coverage 为 `233/144/89/0/0/0`，Content 为 `13 completed / 38 needs_verification`，`adminRiskAction` 为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=true`，对应 `POST /admin-api/muse/content/works/{workId}/risk-actions`；OpenAPI `RiskActionRequest` 已要求 `commandId`、`action`、`reason`、`expectedVersion`，Controller 权限点为 `muse:content:risk-action`，Service 已有事务、command reserve、`selectByIdForUpdate`、expectedVersion 校验、targetScope/targetIds 归属校验、governance action insert 和 command/audit succeeded envelope。推荐目标值仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/145/88/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `14 completed / 37 needs_verification`。下一步必须对该审阅版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 前不得写执行版、修改 scanner/report/gate、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Admin RiskAction Completed Approval 审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Rawls spec/scope review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings，确认审阅版只覆盖 `content:adminRiskAction` 一个 operation-level approval，不推进 Content domain-level completed，不修改 OpenAPI/scanner/report/业务实现，目标 `233/145/88` 与 Content `14/37` 可由当前 `233/144/89` 与 Content `13/38` 加 1 个 operation 机械推导，非目标 37 个 Content operation 与 coverage 差集一致。Kierkegaard quality/feasibility/testing review PASS，无阻塞项，确认 MockMvc HTTP + real PostgreSQL `_test`、method security RBAC、tenant interceptor、command replay/conflict、expectedVersion/row lock、targetScope/targetIds 归属、governance fact、command/audit snapshot、no-write/rollback、Flyway/schema、XML 防空跑和 mixed gate 同步都可落地；非阻断注意为 OpenAPI 已声明 `expectedVersion` required，但生成 DTO 新鲜度不能单独作为合同证据，后续应以 OpenAPI + 服务端 VO validation + HTTP/DB 证据闭合。执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminRiskActionCompletedApproval执行版.md`。执行版只锁定 `content:adminRiskAction`，不把 `content` 加入 domain allowlist，不推进 Content 51/51，不修改 OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration；目标 summary 仅作为获批后执行目标：`233/145/88/0/0/0`，Content 目标为 `14 completed / 37 needs_verification`。下一步必须 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/testing review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Admin RiskAction Completed Approval 执行版 fresh review 进展：Chandrasekhar execution spec/scope review PASS，无 findings，确认执行版严格限定 `content:adminRiskAction` 一个 operation-level completed approval、目标 `233/145/88` 与 Content `14/37` 可机械推导、allowed/prohibited diff 与 mixed gate 同步范围覆盖当前硬编码点。Aquinas execution quality/feasibility/testing review FAIL，3 个问题已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 验证为有效并修订：P1 harness 缺必需 admin web/security bean 细节，已补 `@Bean("ss")` test security service、`ApiErrorLogCommonApi` stub、`MuseWebAutoConfiguration`、真实 `ContentCommandServiceImpl`、真实 `ContentAuditServiceImpl`、真实 `ContentAdminServiceImpl`、所有 Content mapper / facade stub 和 tenant interceptor 要求；P1 command/audit gate 漏 command envelope 行级事实，已补 `muse_content_command_log` 的 tenant_id、command_id、command_type、owner_user_id、target_type、target_id、request_hash，以及 `muse_content_governance_action` 的 tenant/operator/command/audit/action/target/expectedVersion/status 断言；P2 `_test` 数据库准备步骤不完整，已补 standalone 与 combined `_test` 建库命令、password env export 和非 `_test` 拒绝说明。由于执行版已在 review 后修订，Chandrasekhar PASS 需重新确认或至少由下一轮 spec/scope reviewer 基于最新文件复核；Aquinas FAIL 不能计入最终 gate。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution quality/feasibility/testing review，必要时同步 fresh spec/scope re-review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Content completed。

P1R Content Admin RiskAction Completed Approval 执行版 fresh re-review 已双 PASS：Peirce execution spec/scope re-review PASS，确认最新执行版仍只覆盖 `content:adminRiskAction` 一个 operation-level completed approval，不推进 Content domain-level completed，不夹带 admin import/export task、Content CRUD 写命令、OpenAPI、Content main/java 或 SQL migration，目标 `233/145/88` 与 Content `14/37` 可由当前 `233/144/89` 与 Content `13/38` 加 1 个 operation 机械推导；补充的 harness bean set、command/governance 行级断言和 standalone/combined `_test` 建库命令都仍落在测试与门禁范围内。Arendt execution quality/feasibility/testing re-review PASS，确认上一轮 3 项 FAIL 已关闭：执行版已补 exact admin harness bean set、command/audit row + snapshot gate、governance action row fact、standalone / combined `_test` DB 准备、Flyway system property restore、XML 防空跑和 V1-V21 schema gate；未发现会导致 fake pass 或启动失败的 P0/P1/P2/P3 blocker。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入用户批准点，不代表 `content:adminRiskAction` completed；下一步必须由用户明确批准四项执行边界后才允许 implementation，并且 implementation 后仍需 fresh implementation 双 review。

P1R Content Admin RiskAction Completed Approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 `content:adminRiskAction` 一个治理写命令加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `content` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Content 业务实现或 SQL migration。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加 `content:adminRiskAction`；coverage summary 已推进为 `233/145/88/0/0/0`，Content 为 `14 completed / 37 needs_verification`。admin import/export task、Content CRUD 写命令、AI planning candidate、style check、Meta projection、FileService、import/export/parse operation 仍保持 `needs_verification`。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 focused P1R gates 因目标 summary 仍为 144、`adminRiskAction` 仍为 `needs_verification` 而失败；GREEN 后 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 通过并重生成 report。新增 `P1rContentAdminRiskActionCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 `AdminContentController` / `ContentAdminServiceImpl` / `ContentCommandServiceImpl` / `ContentAuditServiceImpl` / mapper、method security + test-local `ss` bean 与 PostgreSQL `_test` 库，单类验证 `8/8 pass`，覆盖安全配置拒绝、V1-V21 schema、`target_ids` JSONB、duplicate command SQLState 23505、`FOR UPDATE` 行锁合同、API version、RBAC、Bean Validation no-write、work/chapter/block happy path、status、replay、command conflict、revision conflict、unsupported action/scope、invalid targetIds、cross-work/cross-tenant target、missing/cross tenant work、command/governance 行级事实、command/audit snapshot 和全表 no-write / rollback。Content focused `ContentAdminServiceTest,AdminContentControllerTest` fresh 运行 `21/21 pass`；Content combined DB gate `P1rContentAdminRiskActionCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentAdminReadCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentPlanningCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentCoreCompletedApprovalIT,P1rContentEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用 `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_content_admin_risk_action_combined_test` fresh 运行 `40/40 pass`；P1R mixed gates fresh 运行 `49/49 pass`；XML 防空跑覆盖 15 个目标类全部 tests>0 且 failures/errors/skipped=0；`git diff --check` 通过；protected OpenAPI diff、Content main/java diff、SQL migration diff 均为空。fresh implementation review 已双 PASS：Gauss scope review PASS、Lagrange data-integrity/testing review PASS，均无 findings。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-13-P1RContentAdminRiskAction状态推进.md`。当前具备提交候选条件，但仍不代表 Content 51/51、Account remaining、Market remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval 已启动并按 testing review 修订审阅版与执行版：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApproval审阅版.md`、`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-13-P1RAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApproval执行版.md`。首轮 scope review（Laplace）PASS，但 testing review（Dalton）FAIL；有效阻塞项为 `appAcknowledgeSecurityEvent` 的 `session_revoked` OpenAPI 合同仍承诺真实 session revoke，而当前实现仅返回“未接入 session 管理服务”的 fail-closed 文案，且 HTTP+DB `_test` 需要明确 `MemberUserMapper.selectById` 依赖的 `member_user` 表 fixture。已修订为本轮候选只覆盖 `account:appListSecurityEvents`、`account:appGetSecurityEvent` 两个 read operation-level completed approval；`account:appAcknowledgeSecurityEvent` 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`。不把 `account` 加入 domain-level completed allowlist，不推进 Account 33/33，不修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Account 业务实现或 SQL migration。当前 coverage 仍为 `233/145/88/0/0/0`，Account 仍为 `10 completed / 23 needs_verification`；执行版目标仅作为获批后目标：`233/147/86/0/0/0`，Account `12 completed / 21 needs_verification`。执行版明确允许在隔离 `_test` 库创建 test-local `member_user` auth fixture 满足 `requireUser()`，但不计入 P1R schema evidence、不修改 production SQL、不允许 mock 目标 mapper。下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh execution quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 前不得实现、提交、push 或推进 Account completed。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval 执行版 review 收到新的 scope P1 并已修订：Kepler fresh scope review FAIL，唯一有效问题是执行版 allowed diff 把既有 `AccountSecurityServiceTest` 与 `AppAccountSecurityControllerTest` 列成可修改路径，超出本轮最小 scope。已按建议收紧执行版 allowed diff：既有 focused tests、mapper/convert tests 只允许作为验证命令和 XML 防空跑证据被运行、读取，不列入本轮可修改路径；如 implementation 必须改既有 focused tests、Account 业务实现、OpenAPI、SQL migration、非批准 gate 或其它文件，必须停下说明原因并重新取得用户批准。Kepler FAIL 之前的 PASS 结论和任何基于旧 allowed diff 的 PASS 均不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须基于收紧后的执行版重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review 与 fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。当前仍只改文档，未修改 scanner、coverage report、OpenAPI、Account 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test，coverage 仍为 `233/145/88/0/0/0`。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval 执行版 fresh testing review（Planck）FAIL，两个 P1 已验证有效并修订：第一，新 `P1rAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApprovalIT` 原固定 `TARGET_VERSION="20"` / V1-V20 clean migrate，但当前 `sql/muse` live baseline 已到 `V21__extend_content_events_publish_outbox.sql`，因此执行版与审阅版已改为新 HTTP+DB IT 必须 `TARGET_VERSION="21"`、V1-V21 clean migrate、`migrationsExecuted=21`；Account 专属 `P1rAccountEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 可继续作为 V20 Account outbox 迁移证据复跑，但不能替代新 IT 的 V21 baseline。第二，test-local `member_user` fixture 只有原则说明，缺可执行 DDL 约束；已补要求 fixture 在隔离 `_test` 库 Flyway migrate 后创建，DDL 至少覆盖 `MemberUserDO`、`TenantBaseDO`、`BaseDO` 当前映射列，包括 `id/mobile/password/status/register_ip/register_terminal/login_ip/login_date/nickname/avatar/name/sex/birthday/area_id/mark/point/tag_ids/level_id/experience/group_id/tenant_id/creator/create_time/updater/update_time/deleted`，不得只建最小列、不得 mock `MemberUserMapper`、不得修改 production SQL。Planck FAIL 和此前任何基于旧 V20/fixture 口径的 PASS 均不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须基于最新版重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review 与 fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。当前仍只改文档，未修改 scanner、coverage report、OpenAPI、Account 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval 执行版 fresh testing review（Anscombe）FAIL，1 个 P1 与 2 个 P2 已验证并修订：P1 为 Task 4 focused verification 会运行新增 `P1rAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApprovalIT`，但命令未传 `_test` JDBC、`p1r.flyway.url/user/locations`，会导致新 IT 缺真实 PostgreSQL `_test` 与 V1-V21 migrate 前置；已补 Task 4 命令，复用 `muse_p1r_account_security_events_completed_approval_test`，导出 `P1R_ACCOUNT_SECURITY_EVENTS_COMPLETED_APPROVAL_JDBC_URL`，创建/复用 `_test` 库，并向 Maven 传 `-Dp1r.flyway.locations=filesystem:sql/muse`、`-Dp1r.flyway.url`、`-Dp1r.flyway.user`、新 IT 专属 JDBC user/url 属性，密码仍只来自环境变量。P2 已补具体 schema 对象名：`idx_muse_member_security_user`、`trg_muse_member_security_updated_at`、`uk_muse_account_security_event_ack_command`、`idx_muse_account_security_event_ack_user`、`idx_muse_account_security_event_ack_event`、`trg_muse_account_security_event_ack_updated_at`。P2 已补 no-write gate 必须对 `muse_member_security_event`、`muse_account_security_event_ack`、`muse_account_command`、`muse_account_audit`、`muse_account_event_publish_outbox` 使用 `row_to_json(t)::text` 全表快照并按稳定键排序，不能只比较 row count。Anscombe FAIL 和此前任何基于旧 Task 4 命令的 PASS 均不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须基于最新版重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review 与 fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。当前仍只改文档，未修改 scanner、coverage report、OpenAPI、Account 业务实现、SQL migration 或 gate test。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval 执行版最新版 fresh review 已双 PASS：Mencius scope review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 findings；Bohr testing/feasibility review PASS，无 P0/P1 blocker。Mencius 确认执行版可进入用户批准点：只审批 `account:appListSecurityEvents`、`account:appGetSecurityEvent` 两个 operation；继续 operation-level approval，不把 `account` 加入 domain allowlist，不推进 Account 33/33；`account:appAcknowledgeSecurityEvent` 继续 `dedicated/needs_verification`；allowed diff 只覆盖 scanner、coverage report、P1R gate tests、新增 `P1rAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApprovalIT`、memory、`.agent`、两份 spec，既有 focused tests 只允许运行/读取；mixed gate 目标为 summary `233/147/86`、Account `12/21`。Bohr 确认 HTTP+DB `_test`、V1-V21 baseline、member_user fixture、no-write、schema/XML/protected diff/rollback 主证据链可进入批准点；其 P2 建议已作为低风险文档补强处理：执行版已明确既有 ack/session_revoked focused tests 只作为现状回归和 XML 防空跑、不计入本轮 completed evidence，并补可复制的 XML 防空跑 Python 校验脚本。该双 PASS 只代表执行版可进入用户批准点，不代表 2 个 Account Security Events read operation completed；未获用户明确批准四项前不得实施 scanner/report/gate/IT 修改。

P1R Account Security Events Completed Approval implementation 当前状态：用户已批准执行版四项前置条件，本轮只把 `account:appListSecurityEvents`、`account:appGetSecurityEvent` 两个只读 operation 加入 operation-level completed approval，未把 `account` 加入 domain-level allowlist，未修改 OpenAPI、Account 业务实现或 SQL migration；`account:appAcknowledgeSecurityEvent` 仍为 `dedicated/needs_verification/requiresCommandId=true`。scanner 仍保持 `APPROVED_COMPLETED_DOMAINS={"ai","knowledge"}`，只追加两个 `account:*` operation key。TDD RED 已验证旧 report 下 P1R focused gates 失败，失败点为 expected completed=147 but was 145、Account expected 12 completed but was 10、`appListSecurityEvents` 仍为 needs_verification；GREEN 后 `python3 muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py --check` 输出 summary `233/147/86/0/0/0`，Account 为 `33/12/21/0/0/0`。新增 `P1rAccountSecurityEventsCompletedApprovalIT` 使用 MockMvc HTTP 入口、真实 `AppAccountSecurityController` / `AccountSecurityServiceImpl` / mapper、PostgreSQL `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_account_security_events_completed_approval_test`，clean migrate V1-V21 后创建 test-local `member_user` fixture，单类验证 `8/8 pass`，覆盖 list/detail、missing/invalid API version、invalid severity、missing user、非数字 eventId、missing/cross owner/cross tenant 404、owner 不能由请求参数覆盖、latest ack 合并、IP/userAgent/token 脱敏、V2/V11/V20/V21 schema、no-write 全表快照和 `_test`/credential safety。Account focused command fresh 运行 muse-server 19/19 pass；member-server focused XML 显示 `AccountSecurityServiceTest 8/8`、`AppAccountSecurityControllerTest 6/6`、`AccountSecurityEventAckMapperTest 4/4`、`MemberSecurityEventMapperTest 2/2`、`AccountConvertTest 9/9`。Account V20 Flyway gate `P1rAccountEventsPublishFlywayMigrationIT` 使用 `_test` 库 `muse_p1r_account_security_events_flyway_test` fresh 运行 `4/4 pass`，输出 `flyway_success=true`、`migrations_executed=20`、`successful_migration_count=20`、`target_schema_version=20`、`flyway_latest=20:extend account events publish outbox`。P1R mixed gates fresh 运行 `49/49 pass`；XML 防空跑覆盖 10 个目标类，全部 tests>0 且 failures/errors/skipped=0；`git diff --check` 通过；protected OpenAPI diff、Account main/java diff、SQL migration diff 均为空。首轮 fresh implementation review 结果：Darwin correctness PASS；Banach testing PASS 且提出 P2 residual（新增 IT 未直接覆盖 `X-API-Version: 2`）已按 `superpowers:receiving-code-review` 验证为低风险有效项并补测试关闭，补充后已 fresh 重跑新增 IT `8/8 pass`、Account focused muse-server `19/19 pass`、P1R mixed gates `49/49 pass`、scanner/report `233/147/86`、XML 防空跑与 protected diff。新增 memory：`docs/memorys/2026-06-13-P1RAccountSecurityEvents状态推进.md`。当前必须重新派发 fresh implementation spec/correctness re-review + fresh implementation quality/data-integrity/testing re-review，双 PASS 前不得提交、push 或宣称 Account 33/33、Market remaining、Content remaining 或总 P1R completed。

P1R Account Remaining 21 解锁审阅版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-14-P1RAccountRemaining21解锁审阅版.md`。当前 live coverage 为 `233/147/86/0/0/0`，Account 为 `33 total / 12 completed / 21 needs_verification`，Meta/AI/Knowledge/Events 已无 remaining，Market 仍 28 remaining，Content 仍 37 remaining。审阅版结论：Account 剩余 21 不应继续作为纯 completed approval 任务推进，必须先进入真实闭环解锁；分组为 New-API / quota request / integration correlation 9 个、FileService / export / download 3 个、usage / call attribution 4 个、Market purchase/license/publish projection 4 个、security ack / session revoke 1 个。该文档未修改 scanner/report/OpenAPI/Account 业务实现/SQL migration，也未宣称任何新增 operation completed。下一步需 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 后才能写执行版。执行版仍只能在用户明确批准后进入真实 implementation，不得用 fail-closed、dedicated gate 或 unit test 直接推进 completed。

P1R Account Remaining 21 解锁审阅版 fresh review 已双 PASS：spec/scope review PASS、feasibility/testing review PASS，均无 P0/P1 阻塞项。reviewer 的有效约束已补入审阅版并落实到执行版：真实 New-API / attribution facade wiring 必须避免 `Unavailable*Facade` 默认实现被静默选中；quota request、attribution job 等写命令必须明确 command、audit、job/outbox 边界；export/download completed 证据必须包含 `muse.account.download-credential-secret`、`fileRef`、过期时间和非空 bytes；新增 HTTP+DB `_test` 必须以 V1-V21 clean migrate 为主证据；Market projection stage 必须覆盖 source fact、projection stale/missing fail-closed、no-write snapshot 与 owner/tenant 隔离；rollback 必须包含 runtime switch / facade fallback，不得只写 scanner/report 回滚。执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-14-P1RAccountRemaining21解锁执行版.md`。当前仍只改 `docs/agent-specs`，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Account 业务实现、SQL migration 或测试代码，也未宣称任何剩余 Account operation completed。下一步需对执行版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review；双 PASS 前不得进入 implementation。

P1R Account Remaining 21 解锁执行版首轮 review：scope review PASS，无 findings；feasibility/testing review FAIL，3 个 P1、2 个 P2、1 个 P3 已验证为有效并修订。执行版已从“路线图”收紧为带默认架构冻结的执行入口：Account 子域持有 Account API/本地事实，New-API、FileService、Market projection、attribution source、session revoke 统一通过 facade / owner API 接入；New-API 与 attribution 的 unavailable facade 默认策略固定为 auto-configuration + `@ConditionalOnMissingBean`，不能继续 `@Component` 与真实 facade 并存；Stage A/C 已写明默认 owner、worker/outbox、runtime switch 和 allowed diff；Stage B 已写明 FileService facade、test-local byte store 最小合同、`muse.account.download-credential-secret`、`fileRef` scheme、sha256、credential DB 断言；Stage D 已标为 blocked until Market source/projection 前置条件完成，并列出 `purchaseAsset`、`installMarketplaceAsset`、publish/review 相关 Market operation 与 projection E2E gate；Stage E 已补 System OAuth2 token owner 作为只读候选入口。执行版新增通用 Maven / `_test` / mixed gate / XML 防空跑 / allowed diff 模板。由于执行版已修订，首轮 PASS/FAIL 不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须重新派发 fresh execution spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review。

P1R Account Remaining 21 解锁执行版 fresh re-review 进展：feasibility/testing re-review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings；scope re-review PASS 但提出 1 个 P2 措辞风险，已修订。修订内容：执行版开头明确 stage 批准只允许修改该 stage 的业务实现、SQL 或测试；scanner、coverage report、completed allowlist 只能在另起 completed approval 中修改；OpenAPI 只能在单独合同变更审批中修改。allowed diff 模板也已收紧为 unlock implementation 始终保护 `docs/api-contracts/**`、`muse-cloud/scripts/p1r-audit-api-coverage.py`、`docs/superpowers/reports/**`，stage plan 不能放开这些路径；如确需修改，必须退出当前 unlock stage 并另起合同变更审批或 completed approval。由于文档在 scope re-review 后修订，需重新做一次 fresh scope re-check；feasibility/testing PASS 仍可作为最新版前一版的重要参考，但最终 gate 以修订后 fresh review 为准。

P1R Account Remaining 21 解锁执行版 final fresh review 已收口：feasibility/testing re-review PASS，无 P0/P1/P2/P3 findings；scope final re-check PASS，确认上一轮 P2 措辞风险已关闭，执行版不直接授权 implementation、不直接授权 completed promotion、不夹带 Market/Content/总 P1R completed。当前有效边界：执行版只允许进入用户批准点；若继续，下一步应由用户选择并批准第一个 implementation stage，推荐从 Stage A New-API / quota / integration 开始，然后先写 stage-level implementation plan 并 fresh 双 review。Stage D Market projection 当前 blocked until Market source/projection 前置条件完成。未获用户明确批准前，不得修改业务实现、SQL、测试、OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 completed allowlist。

P1R 主线远端主分支状态已切换到 `main`：`origin/main` 与 `ali/main` 均已存在且远端 HEAD 指向 `refs/heads/main`，`main`、`origin/main`、`origin/dev/1.0.0`、`ali/main`、`ali/dev/1.0.0` 当前均为 `3a27e7e test(p1r): 收口 Account Security Events completed approval 门禁`。当前 worktree 已从 `dev/1.0.0...origin/dev/1.0.0` 切换为 `main...origin/main`，未提交的 Account Remaining21 文档变更保留；后续开发默认从 `main` 拉取最新代码，再开新分支或在指定主线 worktree 内按用户批准继续。

P1R Account Stage A New-API / Quota / Integration 解锁执行版已新增：`docs/agent-specs/2026-06-14-P1RAccountStageA-NewAPIQuotaIntegration解锁执行版.md`。该文档只用于 Stage A implementation plan 审阅，不是 implementation 授权，也不是 completed approval 授权。Stage A 只覆盖 9 个 operation：`account:adminListNewApiBindings`、`account:adminCreateNewApiBinding`、`account:getAppNewApiBinding`、`account:appRecheckNewApiBinding`、`account:adminCreateQuotaRequest`、`account:appCreateQuotaRequest`、`account:appGetQuotaRequest`、`account:adminGetIntegrationCallByCorrelation`、`account:appGetIntegrationCallByCorrelation`。文档事实基线：coverage 仍为 `233/147/86/0/0/0`，Account 仍为 `33 total / 12 completed / 21 needs_verification`；`UnavailableNewApiAccountFacade` 当前仍是 `@Component` fail-closed 默认实现，`NewApiAccountFacade` 只有 binding/recheck 方法，quota request 当前只创建本地 `muse_account_quota_request(status=queued)` 与 `muse_account_integration_call(status=pending_attribution)`，尚未提交真实 New-API Account runtime；已验证的外部 New-API 证据只覆盖 `/v1/chat/completions`，不覆盖 Account binding/recheck/quota 管理端点。执行版把 Stage A 拆为 A0 facade 装配硬化、A1 New-API Account 管理端点合同查证、A2 binding runtime adapter、A3 quota submit worker、A4 HTTP+DB unlock gate；若 A1 无法查证真实 Account 管理端点，只能停在 A0 和本地闭环测试准备，不能实现伪造 HTTP adapter，也不能推进 9 个 operation completed。当前仍只改 `docs/agent-specs`，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、Account 业务实现、SQL migration 或测试代码；下一步必须对 Stage A 执行版做 fresh spec/scope review + fresh quality/feasibility/testing review，双 PASS 前不得进入 implementation。

P1R Account Stage A 解锁执行版首轮 feasibility/testing review（Hypatia）FAIL，3 项反馈已验证有效并修订：第一，Stage A HTTP+DB `_test` 命令不得通过 `-Dp1r.*password` 传密码，已改为只通过环境变量 `P1R_ACCOUNT_STAGE_A_DB_PASSWORD` / `P1R_FLYWAY_PASSWORD` 读取，并要求 IT 内加入 `assertNoPasswordSystemProperties()`、`assertNoCredentialQuery()` 和 `_test` URL 断言；第二，Remaining21 通用 allowed/protected diff 模板原只用 `git diff --name-only`，不能覆盖 untracked，已改为合并 `git -c core.quotePath=false diff --name-only`、`git -c core.quotePath=false diff --cached --name-only`、`git -c core.quotePath=false ls-files --others --exclude-standard`，避免中文路径被 quotePath 转义后误判；第三，Stage A coverage check 原在 Maven root 语境下使用 repo-root 相对路径，已补明确 `cd /Users/qingse/.config/superpowers/worktrees/oh-my-muse/dev-1.0.0` 后运行 scanner/jq，Maven 命令同步补 `-am`。由于文档已修订，Hypatia FAIL 之前的任何 PASS 不能作为最终 gate；下一步必须基于最新版重新派发 fresh feasibility/testing re-review，并等待 scope review 或按 scope 反馈修订后做 final re-check。

P1R Account Stage A 解锁执行版第二轮 feasibility/testing re-review（Meitner）FAIL，3 个 P1 已按收敛要求最小修订，不再扩展新方案：第一，runtime unavailable 与全表 no-write 语义冲突已拆开，参数校验、幂等冲突、越权、cross tenant、missing resource 仍要求全表 no-write，runtime unavailable 只允许新增或更新一条 `failed/unavailable` integration call，并用 allowed-delta snapshot 证明 binding/quota request、command succeeded fact、audit succeeded fact 和 outbox 没有成功事实；第二，quota submit worker 已冻结为“不新增 SQL migration”默认方案，复用 `muse_account_integration_call.retry_count/next_retry_at/status/errorCode/errorMessage` 承载 retry/lease/dead-letter，quota request 状态只允许 `queued -> processing -> completed/failed`，默认 `maxAttempts=3`，claim/terminal update 必须带 tenant 和状态条件，tenant context 推荐 `TenantContextHolder.setTenantId(...)` 并 finally clear；如需新增字段或索引，必须退出 Stage A unlock 另起 SQL migration 审批；第三，Stage A 与 Remaining21 的 Maven 模板已补 `-am` 和 `-Dsurefire.failIfNoSpecifiedTests=false`。Ramanujan scope review 已 PASS；Meitner FAIL 已修但未重新 review。当前按用户要求立刻收敛、记录进度并整理提交；后续如继续 Stage A implementation，必须基于最新版重新做 feasibility/testing final re-check，双 PASS 前不得 implementation 或 completed promotion。

P1R Account Stage A 解锁执行版 final review 进展：fresh scope final re-check（Maxwell）PASS，无 P0/P1 findings，确认 Stage A 仍只覆盖 9 个 operation，不夹带 Stage B/C/D/E、Account domain completed、Market/Content/总 P1R completed，OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、completed allowlist 仍为保护面；其 P2 基线提交号过期已修为 `862fe9e`。fresh feasibility/testing final review（Huygens）FAIL，2 个 P1 与 1 个 P2 已按收敛要求修订：第一，quota worker 事务边界已冻结为 `claimNext` 独立事务、外部 New-API submit 不在数据库事务内、`finalizeSuccess` / `finalizeFailure` / `finalizeRetryable` 独立短事务，并补外部成功但 finalize 失败时不得二次 submit、后续恢复先查 integration call / externalCallId / correlationId 的要求；第二，Stage A 两条 member Maven 命令已补 `-am` 且保留 `-Dsurefire.failIfNoSpecifiedTests=false`；第三，Stage A 执行版与 memory 的基线提交号已更新为 `862fe9e`。当前仍只改文档，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、业务实现、SQL migration 或测试代码；下一步必须基于最新版重新做 feasibility/testing final re-check，PASS 前不得 implementation 或 completed promotion。

P1R Account Stage A 解锁执行版 narrow final re-check（Sagan）FAIL，1 个 P1 已按收敛要求修订：quota worker retry / lease 恢复状态路径不再二选一，已冻结为初次 claim 从 `queued` 进入 `processing`，retryable 失败保持 quota request 为 `processing` 并只推进 integration call 的 `retry_count/next_retry_at/errorCode/errorMessage`，下一轮 claim 只允许 `processing + next_retry_at <= now` 的恢复路径；HTTP+DB / focused tests 也改为按该唯一路径断言 double-claim、runtime unavailable allowed-delta、finalize conflict、lease 恢复和 maxAttempts terminal failed。Sagan 已确认 Maven `-am` 与 final review 起点基线两个反馈关闭。当前仍只改文档，未修改 OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report、业务实现、SQL migration 或测试代码；下一步必须基于最新版重新做 feasibility/testing final re-check，PASS 前不得 implementation 或 completed promotion。

P1R Account Stage A 解锁执行版 final review 已收口：fresh feasibility/testing final re-check（Volta）PASS，无 P0/P1/P2 findings；Volta 确认 Sagan 唯一 P1 已关闭，执行版已冻结唯一状态路径：初次 claim 从 `queued` 到 `processing`，retryable / runtime unavailable / timeout / 外部 5xx 的 `finalizeRetryable` 必须保持 quota request 为 `processing`，只推进 integration call 的 `retry_count/next_retry_at/errorCode/errorMessage`，下一轮 claim 只允许 `processing + next_retry_at <= now`；测试要求覆盖同一路径的 double-claim、runtime unavailable allowed-delta 且 request 保持 `processing`、finalize conflict、lease 恢复、maxAttempts terminal failed。本轮 final gate 结果为 scope final PASS（Maxwell）+ feasibility/testing final PASS（Volta）。当前 Stage A 执行版可进入用户批准后的 implementation 准备，但仍不是 implementation approved，也不是 completed approval；未获用户明确批准前不得修改业务实现、SQL、测试、OpenAPI、scanner、coverage report 或 completed allowlist。

2.0.0 单人版计划文档同步补记(2026-07-08)：前一提交 `6dcabf69 feat(solo): 收口治理入口并裁剪 studio 表面` 已包含 S4/S5 相关代码、总账与模块 `.agent` 回写,但未把 `docs/agent-specs/2026-07-07-2.0.0单人版改造-execution.md`、`docs/agent-specs/2026-07-07-2.0.0单人版改造-review.md` 和本目录 `.agent` 一起提交。已补齐两项计划口径：其一,S4 除 yudao 九项 `enable=false` 与 yaml 明文 key 清理外,还必须显式关闭 Spring AI Alibaba/DashScope 自装配(`spring.ai.dashscope.agent.enabled=false` 与 `spring.ai.model.*=none`),并由 `SoloExternalAiProviderGateTest` 覆盖;其二,S5 studio 路由/侧栏/account/knowledge 裁剪与 route-only Playwright 已落地,但 MSW-off 创作主线 e2e 仍因标准后端启动的 Flyway V1 function owner mismatch 未完成,不得把 S5 标记为完成。Dify Dataset 拓扑裁决已在 review §5.2 与 execution S6 保持一致:工作区级 Datasets API key 是管理钥匙,生产至少区分全局公共 dataset 与作品独立 dataset,禁止把公共资料和作品私有资料混进单一 dataset 后仅靠 metadata 当安全边界。下一会话优先修 live 后端/测试库 owner 口径并补跑创作主线 e2e。